Freaks of the Heartland #4, July 2004, Dark Horse Comics
writer: Steve Niles
artist: Greg Ruth
If you saw a comic book called Freaks of the Heartland, written by acclaimed 30 Days of Night scribe Steve Niles, wouldn’t you think you were in for a horrific read? Picture the cover: a silhouetted boy, standing against a watercolor sepia tone backdrop, holding a plump, one-eyed rag doll. Needless to say, when I settled down with this issue, I kept the lights on.
For naught. Although this is the fourth issue, this story stands alone as a charming tale of a boy and his deformed brother, running away from home through the grasslands of rural America. Will appears gray-skinned with a prominent under-bite and an abnormally large brow. His speech is simple and possibly slurred, but the connection he shares with his brother, Trevor, is remarkable. “Have I ever asked you ta do something that was bad?” Trevor asks Will when he offers some grubs for sustenance on their journey. Trevor isn’t an obligatory guide; he isn’t running away because of or for his brother, but with him. At the end of this installment, Trevor and Will discover a small burial site, where five rag dolls and two baby skeletons that share Will’s features are unearthed. Trevor figures that his parents lied to him years ago, and that they couldn’t kill all of Will’s brethren. So, the boys vow to find the lost freaks, giving their journey a newfound mission. “We’ll find ‘em,” Trevor proclaims, “and then we’ll all get out of this place.”
Yes, Freaks of the Heartland was a pleasant surprise. The issue was elegantly written, but more notably, stunningly illustrated. Greg Ruth handled the penciling, inking, and coloring responsibilities, so it is evident that he had a vision for this title’s tone from conception to completion. In some panels, the soft, earthen hues overwhelm the line work, establishing the air of a rural atmosphere, and in others, the characters’ features are so finely detailed, I wonder if he used models or photo references to enhance his understanding of a child’s emotional transparency. I just now realize that we the readers are only privy to two characters throughout this story, but the artist uses the background to his advantage as if it becomes an entity itself, and their toil through the farmlands seems less static and repetitive than I’m sure it would really be. You see grass flowing. Sense clouds overhead. It’s an interactively moody experience.
So much for chalking another comic up to my Halloween-themed reviews roster. No, I take that back. Freaks of the Heartland may not have been a harrowing tale, but it speaks to the Halloween tradition, and accredits comics to a genre of literature it often yet ironically forsakes: young adult fiction. What is Halloween if it isn’t kids bonding behind grotesque masks over something as innocent as a love for candy? And what happened to the days when a comic book could depict a child as an emotive little human being, rather than some cartoon or plot device? “Young comics” are usually silly, and kids in comics are usually story fodder, but for perhaps the first time, Niles and Ruth have revealed a tender side to the medium, a paternal side, if you will. I feel for these kids. Now, that’s freaky.
Sunday, October 08, 2006
Saturday, October 07, 2006
Oz Squad #4
Oz Squad #4, Patchwork Press
writer: Steven Ahlquist
penciller: Andrew Murphy
inker: David Lee Ingersoll
letterer: Mike Sagara
editor: Adam Miner
I don’t believe in coincidences. So, I’m not surprised that I found another issue of Oz Squad today, the same day I discovered that Roger Waters is performing a sold-out concert series at the Hollywood Bowl this weekend, recreating Pink Floyd’s famous Dark Side of the Moon. What’s the connection? I should explain.
Several years ago, shortly after my comic book collecting career began, I found two early issues of a little known series called Oz Squad. In this contemporary interpretation of Baum’s classic characters, an adult Dorothy was a special agent in charge of the Gale Force, an elite team of agents comprised of her three friends from the yellow-brick road: a now-existentially philosophizing Scarecrow, a heavily armored Tin-man (known colloquially by his common name Nick), and the Lion, who, not so cowardly, transformed from man to beast with ease. The issues I read featured the team, having established a diplomatic treaty between Earth and Oz, battling Rebecca Eastwitch and her flying monkeys over the coveted blueprints for the potentially lethal Tik-Tok, if I remember correctly. (I could look them up, but I feel like I’d be cheating.) I enjoyed them and wanted more. Hundreds of comics shop visits and a few Comic Cons later, nothing. Today, with little else to do, I easily convinced my galpal to go to the Frank and Sons Collectibles Show here in Southern California, a weekly pop culture/sports memorabilia warehouse expo. Thumbing through some quarter boxes to fuel the A Comic A Day challenge for a few weeks, I found it: Oz Squad #4. I knew we had to go to Franks and Sons for a reason.
What’s Oz Squad have to do with Roger Waters, you ask? Well, the answer is as long as my previous paragraph, so bear with me. My senior year in high school, my friends and I first heard of the Wizard of Oz/Dark Side of the Moon connection, which claims, in a nutshell, that Pink Floyd intended that their best-selling album become an auxiliary soundtrack for the MGM classic – an idea truly ripped from the psychedelic seventies. Intrigued, my friends and I researched the specifics, purchased the album, rented the movie, and tested the theory, with surprising results. Indeed, potentially hundreds of moments throughout the Wizard of Oz synchronize with various musical or lyrical patterns from Dark Side of the Moon, so much so that the effort must have been purposeful. Since our initial attempts at synchronicity were crude, one night we downloaded the Wizard of Oz (before downloading was a common practice, and by actually connecting the television to the computer), digitally arranged the moment when the two mediums met (after the third roar of the MGM lion, if you must know), and looped the album to run its length a complete two and half times through the full length of the film. Without going into more detail, I insist, you must try it. Since then, I’ve been a Pink Floyd fan, and had I realized Roger Waters was in town, I would’ve made an effort to see his concert tomorrow night. Instead, I found an issue of Oz Squad. That’s the connection.
Now, on to an actual comic book review, shall we? In Oz Squad #4, Tik-Tok has turned to the dark side and is climbing his way to the top of the New York City underworld by assassinating competing mobs. Dorothy and her team have forty-eight hours to find him before the CIA relinquish his diplomatic immunity and pursue his arrest. Anticipating their arrival, Tik-Tok sets up a decoy to distract his old friends; Tin Man loses his legs in a garbage crusher, and the Scarecrow doses himself in gas to avoid a henchwoman’s blowtorch attack. In the end, the CIA arrest Tik-Tok’s decoy, so the real deal is still at large, but in light of their near defeat, the Gale Force settles for an opportunity to nurse their wounds. An interesting tale of Phyrric victory.
Steven Ahlquist isn’t simply writing a “contemporary interpretation of Baum’s classic characters,” as I originally described. Ahlquist has sophisticatedly explored how icons of innocence, like Dorothy and her iconic friends, would react and transform through today’s cultural and political lens. Further, each character has not only conquered their memorable shortcomings, but has been consumed by their own self-confidence, transforming the Lion, for example, into a bestial warrior willing to dive headfirst into danger. The Scarecrow seems content dwelling in the dark recesses of his own mind, and the Tinman is so passionate about his work, his state-of-the-art body is often ironically mangled in battle. However, Dorothy is the most compelled of all, still trying to maintain the sanctity of Oz in our world’s tumultuous political landscape. Ahlquist sums her up perfectly when Tik-Tok wryly muses, “Our only hope now is that Dorothy has not lost her penchant for walking into traps.” Then, again, when Dorothy beseeches him to repent of his crimes, “And you once claimed that you were unaffected by your aunt’s Baptist teachings.” Some writers would have been tempted to exploit this concept as a comedy of errors, with satiric jabs at the source material, but Ahlquist establishes a legitimate character study, one part modern fairy tale, one part black comedy, one part psychological thriller. Everything Oz would’ve been if it was intended for adults in the first place.
Artistically, Oz Squad isn’t the best-drawn book, but it gets the job done. Murphy has a handle on dramatic blocking and panel layout, and he and Ingersoll pull off some impressive effects with just line and ink, but color would’ve added some necessary depth to these otherwise stark pages. Ahlquist may write some insightful stuff, but every Oz Squad issue I’ve read thus far builds to an explosive action sequence. Ruby slippers, a yellow-brick road, an emerald city . . . these characters have always been colorful.
I will have to dig up those old book sometime soon, because I think this issue was released a significant amount of time after the others. The author’s embittered notes at the end of this story imply that some vested third parties have tried to stick their fingers in his pie, so I wonder if his dynamic ideas sparked as much fanaticism for this series as I’ve had trying to find it these past several years. That’s what happens when your head explodes with dark forebodings of classic literature. Unfortunately, I’m right back where I was before – humming, “If I only had another issue.” De-do-de-do-do-do-do.
writer: Steven Ahlquist
penciller: Andrew Murphy
inker: David Lee Ingersoll
letterer: Mike Sagara
editor: Adam Miner
I don’t believe in coincidences. So, I’m not surprised that I found another issue of Oz Squad today, the same day I discovered that Roger Waters is performing a sold-out concert series at the Hollywood Bowl this weekend, recreating Pink Floyd’s famous Dark Side of the Moon. What’s the connection? I should explain.
Several years ago, shortly after my comic book collecting career began, I found two early issues of a little known series called Oz Squad. In this contemporary interpretation of Baum’s classic characters, an adult Dorothy was a special agent in charge of the Gale Force, an elite team of agents comprised of her three friends from the yellow-brick road: a now-existentially philosophizing Scarecrow, a heavily armored Tin-man (known colloquially by his common name Nick), and the Lion, who, not so cowardly, transformed from man to beast with ease. The issues I read featured the team, having established a diplomatic treaty between Earth and Oz, battling Rebecca Eastwitch and her flying monkeys over the coveted blueprints for the potentially lethal Tik-Tok, if I remember correctly. (I could look them up, but I feel like I’d be cheating.) I enjoyed them and wanted more. Hundreds of comics shop visits and a few Comic Cons later, nothing. Today, with little else to do, I easily convinced my galpal to go to the Frank and Sons Collectibles Show here in Southern California, a weekly pop culture/sports memorabilia warehouse expo. Thumbing through some quarter boxes to fuel the A Comic A Day challenge for a few weeks, I found it: Oz Squad #4. I knew we had to go to Franks and Sons for a reason.
What’s Oz Squad have to do with Roger Waters, you ask? Well, the answer is as long as my previous paragraph, so bear with me. My senior year in high school, my friends and I first heard of the Wizard of Oz/Dark Side of the Moon connection, which claims, in a nutshell, that Pink Floyd intended that their best-selling album become an auxiliary soundtrack for the MGM classic – an idea truly ripped from the psychedelic seventies. Intrigued, my friends and I researched the specifics, purchased the album, rented the movie, and tested the theory, with surprising results. Indeed, potentially hundreds of moments throughout the Wizard of Oz synchronize with various musical or lyrical patterns from Dark Side of the Moon, so much so that the effort must have been purposeful. Since our initial attempts at synchronicity were crude, one night we downloaded the Wizard of Oz (before downloading was a common practice, and by actually connecting the television to the computer), digitally arranged the moment when the two mediums met (after the third roar of the MGM lion, if you must know), and looped the album to run its length a complete two and half times through the full length of the film. Without going into more detail, I insist, you must try it. Since then, I’ve been a Pink Floyd fan, and had I realized Roger Waters was in town, I would’ve made an effort to see his concert tomorrow night. Instead, I found an issue of Oz Squad. That’s the connection.
Now, on to an actual comic book review, shall we? In Oz Squad #4, Tik-Tok has turned to the dark side and is climbing his way to the top of the New York City underworld by assassinating competing mobs. Dorothy and her team have forty-eight hours to find him before the CIA relinquish his diplomatic immunity and pursue his arrest. Anticipating their arrival, Tik-Tok sets up a decoy to distract his old friends; Tin Man loses his legs in a garbage crusher, and the Scarecrow doses himself in gas to avoid a henchwoman’s blowtorch attack. In the end, the CIA arrest Tik-Tok’s decoy, so the real deal is still at large, but in light of their near defeat, the Gale Force settles for an opportunity to nurse their wounds. An interesting tale of Phyrric victory.
Steven Ahlquist isn’t simply writing a “contemporary interpretation of Baum’s classic characters,” as I originally described. Ahlquist has sophisticatedly explored how icons of innocence, like Dorothy and her iconic friends, would react and transform through today’s cultural and political lens. Further, each character has not only conquered their memorable shortcomings, but has been consumed by their own self-confidence, transforming the Lion, for example, into a bestial warrior willing to dive headfirst into danger. The Scarecrow seems content dwelling in the dark recesses of his own mind, and the Tinman is so passionate about his work, his state-of-the-art body is often ironically mangled in battle. However, Dorothy is the most compelled of all, still trying to maintain the sanctity of Oz in our world’s tumultuous political landscape. Ahlquist sums her up perfectly when Tik-Tok wryly muses, “Our only hope now is that Dorothy has not lost her penchant for walking into traps.” Then, again, when Dorothy beseeches him to repent of his crimes, “And you once claimed that you were unaffected by your aunt’s Baptist teachings.” Some writers would have been tempted to exploit this concept as a comedy of errors, with satiric jabs at the source material, but Ahlquist establishes a legitimate character study, one part modern fairy tale, one part black comedy, one part psychological thriller. Everything Oz would’ve been if it was intended for adults in the first place.
Artistically, Oz Squad isn’t the best-drawn book, but it gets the job done. Murphy has a handle on dramatic blocking and panel layout, and he and Ingersoll pull off some impressive effects with just line and ink, but color would’ve added some necessary depth to these otherwise stark pages. Ahlquist may write some insightful stuff, but every Oz Squad issue I’ve read thus far builds to an explosive action sequence. Ruby slippers, a yellow-brick road, an emerald city . . . these characters have always been colorful.
I will have to dig up those old book sometime soon, because I think this issue was released a significant amount of time after the others. The author’s embittered notes at the end of this story imply that some vested third parties have tried to stick their fingers in his pie, so I wonder if his dynamic ideas sparked as much fanaticism for this series as I’ve had trying to find it these past several years. That’s what happens when your head explodes with dark forebodings of classic literature. Unfortunately, I’m right back where I was before – humming, “If I only had another issue.” De-do-de-do-do-do-do.
Friday, October 06, 2006
Gross Point #11
Gross Point #11, May 1998, DC Comics
writer: Matt Wayne
penciller: Joe Stanton
inker/letterer: Roger Landridge
colorist: Ian Laughlin
editor: Martin Pasko
Don't judge a book by its cover. We've all heard it. Gross Point proves it. When I read the cover's teaser, "He turns into a monster at the touch of a pretty girl!" I assumed that Gross Point was a modern horror/humor comic, perhaps featuring two or three tale of macabre science fiction/fantasy. No way that concept could flesh out into a twenty-two page story, I thought. Yup. I was wrong.
Gross Point is a city (not to be confused with the real Grosse Point, Michigan, as a disclaimer carefully explains) with plenty of dirt, demons, and dilapidation, contrasted by the bright, clean neighborhood Collier Bluff. Meat (yes, that's his name) and Terri are from opposite sides of the street, but not the sides you would think. Terri is from Gross Point, but the only abnormality about her is her eagerness to take her relationship with Meat to the next level. Meat refuses to dare venture to even first base because, you guess it, "he turns into a monster at the touch of a pretty girl." He convinces Terri that he's in the drama club at school -- why this would sedate her, I have no idea -- so when Terri ditches school to confirm his claim, Meat quickly stumbles into his school's all girl performance of Julius Caesar. "Hilarity" ensues as Meat tries to avoid the grabby girls and the school bully, until he finally makes amends with Terri. Now, I don't mean he tells her the truth; he just comes up with another lame excuse to avoid her pesky touch, at least for another issue. The story is, as I surmised when I realized its length, pointless.
Maybe I'm missing the point. Maybe Gross Point was intended for a younger audience. It is illustrated like a Mad Magazine strip. However, its narrative contains carefully scribbled expletives, which look more like the letterer's mistakes than strategic swearing. Even as a kid, I could've assumed which bad words the writer intended, using context clues. So is the creative team that careless, or was Gross Point really intended for the sophisticated, steadfast comic collector? Heck, this story references the title's own continuity more than some mainstream superhero books I've read, as if each issue isn't episodic. As if each issue didn't feature some goofy Gross Point freakshow. What I presumed to be a simple read became more complicated than I anticipated.
So, Gross Point was neither horrific or comedic. It was just plain disappointing. It barely falls under the "Halloween review" category -- all trick, no treat. Now I'm in a sour mood. "He turns into a grouch at the touch of a bad comic book!"
writer: Matt Wayne
penciller: Joe Stanton
inker/letterer: Roger Landridge
colorist: Ian Laughlin
editor: Martin Pasko
Don't judge a book by its cover. We've all heard it. Gross Point proves it. When I read the cover's teaser, "He turns into a monster at the touch of a pretty girl!" I assumed that Gross Point was a modern horror/humor comic, perhaps featuring two or three tale of macabre science fiction/fantasy. No way that concept could flesh out into a twenty-two page story, I thought. Yup. I was wrong.
Gross Point is a city (not to be confused with the real Grosse Point, Michigan, as a disclaimer carefully explains) with plenty of dirt, demons, and dilapidation, contrasted by the bright, clean neighborhood Collier Bluff. Meat (yes, that's his name) and Terri are from opposite sides of the street, but not the sides you would think. Terri is from Gross Point, but the only abnormality about her is her eagerness to take her relationship with Meat to the next level. Meat refuses to dare venture to even first base because, you guess it, "he turns into a monster at the touch of a pretty girl." He convinces Terri that he's in the drama club at school -- why this would sedate her, I have no idea -- so when Terri ditches school to confirm his claim, Meat quickly stumbles into his school's all girl performance of Julius Caesar. "Hilarity" ensues as Meat tries to avoid the grabby girls and the school bully, until he finally makes amends with Terri. Now, I don't mean he tells her the truth; he just comes up with another lame excuse to avoid her pesky touch, at least for another issue. The story is, as I surmised when I realized its length, pointless.
Maybe I'm missing the point. Maybe Gross Point was intended for a younger audience. It is illustrated like a Mad Magazine strip. However, its narrative contains carefully scribbled expletives, which look more like the letterer's mistakes than strategic swearing. Even as a kid, I could've assumed which bad words the writer intended, using context clues. So is the creative team that careless, or was Gross Point really intended for the sophisticated, steadfast comic collector? Heck, this story references the title's own continuity more than some mainstream superhero books I've read, as if each issue isn't episodic. As if each issue didn't feature some goofy Gross Point freakshow. What I presumed to be a simple read became more complicated than I anticipated.
So, Gross Point was neither horrific or comedic. It was just plain disappointing. It barely falls under the "Halloween review" category -- all trick, no treat. Now I'm in a sour mood. "He turns into a grouch at the touch of a bad comic book!"
Thursday, October 05, 2006
Thundercats #1
Thundercats #1, October 2002, Wildstorm Productions
writer: Ford Lytle Gilmore
penciller: Ed McGuinness
inker: Jason Martin
colorist: Chris Walker with Wildstorm
letterer: John Layman with Sergio Garcia
editor: Jeff Mariotte
Yes, I watched Thundercats, but I was no means an avid follower. I’m a Masters of the Universe guy. That said, I was curious how the Gilmore/McGuinness/Martin team (since publications rarely mention the letterer or colorist) would handle this precious property, this proverbial time capsule of nostalgic lore. This miniseries was released in the midst of an ‘80s renaissance, and at that time, the hype for these titles was tremendous. “See your favorite childhood heroes handled with the respect and maturity they deserve!” was the unspoken pitch. “The original fans of Thundercats, He-Man, G.I. Joe, etc. are older and more sophisticated now! We plan on publishing stories that speak to them on that level!” I remember, I was excited.
Until the issues were released.
Don’t get me wrong. These comics are beautifully packaged. The Masters of the Universe title (which I collected for a few months) was very well illustrated. Unfortunately, the story stank. I’d read better fan fiction. Apparently, based on my impression of this issue, Thundercats suffered from the same fate.
In this first chapter, Thundera is restored to its original splendor, from before the evils of Mumm-Ra and his minions. Of course, the governing powers of the dark arts are not pleased with this, so as Lion-O and his friends make plans to broadcast a subspace all-is-well message to their brethren across the galaxy, the Shadowmaster is summoned to finish off the Thundercats once and for all. His shadow beasts hold the ‘Cats at bay for a few moments but are predictably defeated by the light from the eye of Thundera. In the end, despite their earlier complaints about his futile efforts, the dark mystics resurrect Mumm-Ra, after which I assume the real action will begin.
As I implied, this story was a quick read, action-packed and too shallow to, ironically, pack a real punch. So, since I usually elaborate on the plot, today I will offer some thoughts about the art. McGuinness is a love-him-or-hate-him artist. Some fans thoroughly enjoyed his run on Superman; others found his style too cartoony to be taken seriously. I understand their perspective, but I like his style, especially in the context of a cartoon adaptation comic. So what if all of his characters look alike? Those old cartoonists understood the importance of a visually distinctive character, a trick that helped with the frequent recycling of animation cells and sequences. In the Thundercats’ case, each character has a specific color scheme about them, and as simple as that sounds, it actually helps. (For example, if Lion-O wasn’t orange and touched up with cat-like features, his face would be a dead ringer’s for a certain Man of Steel, through the skills of McGuinness.) McGuinness respects the lore, too; when Lion-O summons the ‘Cats, the panel sequence is a veritable storyboard from the cartoon’s defining sword-sprouting sequence. He-Man artists never got his transformation right.
So, the where-are-they-nows have become where-are-they-nows. Thundercats, He-Man, and the others went as quickly as they came. The blitz to market these books shortchanged their ability to stick. These franchises deserve more than that. In another five years or so, maybe we’ll see them again. Until then, they will stand as nothing more than puff pieces for up and coming artists. Putting the ho back in Thundercats, HO!
writer: Ford Lytle Gilmore
penciller: Ed McGuinness
inker: Jason Martin
colorist: Chris Walker with Wildstorm
letterer: John Layman with Sergio Garcia
editor: Jeff Mariotte
Yes, I watched Thundercats, but I was no means an avid follower. I’m a Masters of the Universe guy. That said, I was curious how the Gilmore/McGuinness/Martin team (since publications rarely mention the letterer or colorist) would handle this precious property, this proverbial time capsule of nostalgic lore. This miniseries was released in the midst of an ‘80s renaissance, and at that time, the hype for these titles was tremendous. “See your favorite childhood heroes handled with the respect and maturity they deserve!” was the unspoken pitch. “The original fans of Thundercats, He-Man, G.I. Joe, etc. are older and more sophisticated now! We plan on publishing stories that speak to them on that level!” I remember, I was excited.
Until the issues were released.
Don’t get me wrong. These comics are beautifully packaged. The Masters of the Universe title (which I collected for a few months) was very well illustrated. Unfortunately, the story stank. I’d read better fan fiction. Apparently, based on my impression of this issue, Thundercats suffered from the same fate.
In this first chapter, Thundera is restored to its original splendor, from before the evils of Mumm-Ra and his minions. Of course, the governing powers of the dark arts are not pleased with this, so as Lion-O and his friends make plans to broadcast a subspace all-is-well message to their brethren across the galaxy, the Shadowmaster is summoned to finish off the Thundercats once and for all. His shadow beasts hold the ‘Cats at bay for a few moments but are predictably defeated by the light from the eye of Thundera. In the end, despite their earlier complaints about his futile efforts, the dark mystics resurrect Mumm-Ra, after which I assume the real action will begin.
As I implied, this story was a quick read, action-packed and too shallow to, ironically, pack a real punch. So, since I usually elaborate on the plot, today I will offer some thoughts about the art. McGuinness is a love-him-or-hate-him artist. Some fans thoroughly enjoyed his run on Superman; others found his style too cartoony to be taken seriously. I understand their perspective, but I like his style, especially in the context of a cartoon adaptation comic. So what if all of his characters look alike? Those old cartoonists understood the importance of a visually distinctive character, a trick that helped with the frequent recycling of animation cells and sequences. In the Thundercats’ case, each character has a specific color scheme about them, and as simple as that sounds, it actually helps. (For example, if Lion-O wasn’t orange and touched up with cat-like features, his face would be a dead ringer’s for a certain Man of Steel, through the skills of McGuinness.) McGuinness respects the lore, too; when Lion-O summons the ‘Cats, the panel sequence is a veritable storyboard from the cartoon’s defining sword-sprouting sequence. He-Man artists never got his transformation right.
So, the where-are-they-nows have become where-are-they-nows. Thundercats, He-Man, and the others went as quickly as they came. The blitz to market these books shortchanged their ability to stick. These franchises deserve more than that. In another five years or so, maybe we’ll see them again. Until then, they will stand as nothing more than puff pieces for up and coming artists. Putting the ho back in Thundercats, HO!
Wednesday, October 04, 2006
The Skull Man #2
The Skull Man #2, ToykoPop Manga
by Kazuhiko Shimamoto & Shotaro Ishinomori
I’m going to make this one short and sweet. I’m sick, and I’ve taken a sleeping pill. In case you were interested.
The Skull Man struck me as a fortuitous find for two reasons: (1.) the skull motif is Halloweenish enough to fit this month’s theme, and (2.) I’m always interested in reading more manga, if only to see if I can find a story I can understand. Unfortunately, The Skull Man didn’t cut it. Originally published in Japan in 1998, this issue’s text is interpreted by Ray Yoshimoto, and although I haven’t read the original material, I can only assume that Yoshimoto’s take was a transliteration, or a word-for-word recount of the original narrative. The syntax is simplistic and sloppy, and the story is difficult to follow. From what I’ve gather, the Skull Man is at odds with the Spider Man (not that Spider-Man) over some disk of information that may explain the Skull Man’s mysterious origins. This issue barely conveyed this concept, let alone made advances in the story. Then again, maybe it’s just a cultural thing.
I might have postulated this before, but the idea is worth mentioning again: manga is very in with the kids right now. I’m wondering if they understand and appreciate more so than I can because they’ve begun reading it at an earlier age. Just as it’s easier for younger people to learn a foreign language, perhaps children can better interpret a foreign visual or graphic format, as well. I know it’s Pulitzer week for the sciences. Somebody get on the study, quick.
Speaking of visuals, some of these pages are just plain stunning. The artist’s wide, establishing shots are intricate yet easy on the eye, without overwhelming detail but enough to establish a solid setting and mood. I particularly enjoyed the sequence that took place at the Korean BBQ, where two investigators’ dialogue was interspersed with images of beef sizzling on the grill. Interesting illustrative technique, and characteristic of manga, from what little I’ve read. The Skull Man may be a warrior of the living dead, but his comic book keeps the traditions of his genre alive and well.
Not a bad review considering I’m under the influence of a sleep-inducer. Time for my skull to hit the pillow.
by Kazuhiko Shimamoto & Shotaro Ishinomori
I’m going to make this one short and sweet. I’m sick, and I’ve taken a sleeping pill. In case you were interested.
The Skull Man struck me as a fortuitous find for two reasons: (1.) the skull motif is Halloweenish enough to fit this month’s theme, and (2.) I’m always interested in reading more manga, if only to see if I can find a story I can understand. Unfortunately, The Skull Man didn’t cut it. Originally published in Japan in 1998, this issue’s text is interpreted by Ray Yoshimoto, and although I haven’t read the original material, I can only assume that Yoshimoto’s take was a transliteration, or a word-for-word recount of the original narrative. The syntax is simplistic and sloppy, and the story is difficult to follow. From what I’ve gather, the Skull Man is at odds with the Spider Man (not that Spider-Man) over some disk of information that may explain the Skull Man’s mysterious origins. This issue barely conveyed this concept, let alone made advances in the story. Then again, maybe it’s just a cultural thing.
I might have postulated this before, but the idea is worth mentioning again: manga is very in with the kids right now. I’m wondering if they understand and appreciate more so than I can because they’ve begun reading it at an earlier age. Just as it’s easier for younger people to learn a foreign language, perhaps children can better interpret a foreign visual or graphic format, as well. I know it’s Pulitzer week for the sciences. Somebody get on the study, quick.
Speaking of visuals, some of these pages are just plain stunning. The artist’s wide, establishing shots are intricate yet easy on the eye, without overwhelming detail but enough to establish a solid setting and mood. I particularly enjoyed the sequence that took place at the Korean BBQ, where two investigators’ dialogue was interspersed with images of beef sizzling on the grill. Interesting illustrative technique, and characteristic of manga, from what little I’ve read. The Skull Man may be a warrior of the living dead, but his comic book keeps the traditions of his genre alive and well.
Not a bad review considering I’m under the influence of a sleep-inducer. Time for my skull to hit the pillow.
Tuesday, October 03, 2006
The 7 Guys of Justice #10
The 7 Guys of Justice #10, October 2001, False Idol Studios
writer: Brian Joines
artist: Joshua Rowe
letterer: Michael Thomas
I attended a funeral today. The whole lower-the-body-into-the-ground shebang. I’ve never been to a ceremony like that before. Of course, I’ve been to funerals, but my family traditionally cremates its dead, so my experience with graveside rituals is limited to film and comic books. Comics like The 7 Guys of Justice.
Funny. I gave 7 Guys the flip test on Saturday and was ready to read it, but an impromptu trip to a comics shop introduced me to Stan Lee Meets Spider-Man, the perfect issue to celebrate the A Comic A Day project’s first three months. Now, I open The 7 Guys of Justice, and where are our heroes? Watching an ally descend into the ground. I couldn’t have planned it better if I intended to, but believe me, I didn’t.
My favorite part of reading a new superhero comic book is often the names the creators have come up with for their protagonists. Astro City and Top 10 have some cool super monikers, but to its credit, these 7 Guys take the cake. Nightie Knight, Hunter-Gather, the villainous Bad Art . . . very clever. Unfortunately, that’s where my appreciation for this issue ends.
In this chapter, heroes are disappeared, abducted by Mussolini’s head, which is alive and well in a special jar. The team uses the Surprise’s signal device (another fun name, but one that should be italicized because of its commonality as a regular word) to trace the Tenth Reich’s location – the others weren’t successful – where the goofy Talon, best described as a Harvey Birdman rip-off, a spoof of a spoof, you see, is the only one to emerge unbrainwashed. A few heroes show up at the end, familiar to faithful readers I presume, in a “to be continued” twist. Yay.
I like a few of the ideas the writer rapidly glosses over here, to imply a depth to the 7 Guys’ superhero world, but Joines is way too wordy to let any of the good stuff really sink in. His attempts at humor require a heartier touch of subtlety; his subplot-ridden interludes need more explanation to provide new readers like me a context with which to really enjoy them. The writer’s attention is in all the wrong places.
Further, this issue is loaded is typos. Words are missing letters or blatantly misspelled, some of the sentence’s structure is awkward and just plain incorrect, and the speech balloons are poorly arranged so some panels do not read the way they were intended. It’s very distracting, and in the end, I was looking for it. Never a good sign.
Although this issue begins with a compelling cemetery scene, the rest of the story is rather light-hearted. A relief from today’s real life events. The 7 Guys of Justice may not be my champions of choice, but when they’re the only ones that show up, they get the job done. Sometimes that’s the only thing you can ask for from a hero.
writer: Brian Joines
artist: Joshua Rowe
letterer: Michael Thomas
I attended a funeral today. The whole lower-the-body-into-the-ground shebang. I’ve never been to a ceremony like that before. Of course, I’ve been to funerals, but my family traditionally cremates its dead, so my experience with graveside rituals is limited to film and comic books. Comics like The 7 Guys of Justice.
Funny. I gave 7 Guys the flip test on Saturday and was ready to read it, but an impromptu trip to a comics shop introduced me to Stan Lee Meets Spider-Man, the perfect issue to celebrate the A Comic A Day project’s first three months. Now, I open The 7 Guys of Justice, and where are our heroes? Watching an ally descend into the ground. I couldn’t have planned it better if I intended to, but believe me, I didn’t.
My favorite part of reading a new superhero comic book is often the names the creators have come up with for their protagonists. Astro City and Top 10 have some cool super monikers, but to its credit, these 7 Guys take the cake. Nightie Knight, Hunter-Gather, the villainous Bad Art . . . very clever. Unfortunately, that’s where my appreciation for this issue ends.
In this chapter, heroes are disappeared, abducted by Mussolini’s head, which is alive and well in a special jar. The team uses the Surprise’s signal device (another fun name, but one that should be italicized because of its commonality as a regular word) to trace the Tenth Reich’s location – the others weren’t successful – where the goofy Talon, best described as a Harvey Birdman rip-off, a spoof of a spoof, you see, is the only one to emerge unbrainwashed. A few heroes show up at the end, familiar to faithful readers I presume, in a “to be continued” twist. Yay.
I like a few of the ideas the writer rapidly glosses over here, to imply a depth to the 7 Guys’ superhero world, but Joines is way too wordy to let any of the good stuff really sink in. His attempts at humor require a heartier touch of subtlety; his subplot-ridden interludes need more explanation to provide new readers like me a context with which to really enjoy them. The writer’s attention is in all the wrong places.
Further, this issue is loaded is typos. Words are missing letters or blatantly misspelled, some of the sentence’s structure is awkward and just plain incorrect, and the speech balloons are poorly arranged so some panels do not read the way they were intended. It’s very distracting, and in the end, I was looking for it. Never a good sign.
Although this issue begins with a compelling cemetery scene, the rest of the story is rather light-hearted. A relief from today’s real life events. The 7 Guys of Justice may not be my champions of choice, but when they’re the only ones that show up, they get the job done. Sometimes that’s the only thing you can ask for from a hero.
Quarterly Report: July-September 2006
During the first quarter of the A Comic A Day challenge, I have encountered every obstacle I imagined possible when I planned the project back in June. In the past three months, I have been without a new-to-me comic book to read (that upheld the restrictions I established in the beginning), I have suffered from an unstable Internet connection, I have had to work twelve-hour days with little time to read let alone post a comprehensive review, and most recently, I have lost an old friend. (Old is the operative word. Tom had one foot in the ground for a long time. Doesn't make his passing any less unfortunate.) A year is a long time. I told myself these things could happen. Thankfully, since all of them have, the next three months should pass with little incident, right? Right?
Looking at the long list of comic books I've read since July, I'm struggling to define this experience thus far. As I'd hoped, the comic books I've sampled represent the diversity of the medium, from era to artist to genre. Fortunately, A Comic A Day began on the cusp of the San Diego Comic Con, which fueled this project for an entire month. However, with the intention of experiencing as wide a variety as possible, I have found some local sources of graphic goodness that I wouldn't have thought of before. Pawn shops, hobby shops, and antique stores have been reliable sources for obscure material in a pinch, especially as I venture into themed reviews, like this month's appropriate series of posts re: horror/supernatural comics. Of course, living in Southern California is an advantage in itself; I can't ride my bike without running over somebody's demo tape. Pop culture is celebrated here. If I lived in Oklahoma, who knows if I'd find such a selection?
Further, since A Comic A Day is an exercise in artistic interaction, I've decided that desperation is at the core of quality comic book creating. Up and coming artists are desperate to create something new, while established artists, most likely working on equally established titles or characters, are desperate to do something new, lest their critics accuse them of rehashing past stories, styles, and concepts. Perusing my list of entries, Virgin Comics, God the Dyslexic Dog, and Don't Eat the Electric Sheep are excellent examples of artists mining fresh concepts to produce a different kind of comic book, either culturally, spiritually, or existentially, respectively in these cases. On the other hand, issues like Superman #300, Zot! #29, and Invincible #1 are decent attempts at reestablishing the superhero as a relevant paradigm in fiction. Both categories boast their hits and misses, and I've already read them all. (I'm looking at you, Captain Paragon.) The question is, is art "good enough" as an attempt, or a successful effort?
The answer to that question defines the concept of art itself. Dim-witted Darryl may not have been my cup of tea, but I'm sure someone somewhere has fanatically collected every issue and is eagerly anticipating new material, if that series is still on the shelves today. What I look for in a comic book, what connects with me on a literary and/or artistic level, isn't going be in everyone else's tastes. Moreover, I may recognize a comic book as a legitimate effort, but an entertaining read doesn't always entail a commitment to a title. Sometimes, a glimpse is all we need. Who knows if Mona Lisa had a decent body? It's that smile we remember. It was good enough.
Most importantly, I'm enjoying this experience, and I'm grateful that some of these comic books that otherwise I never would have experienced have now made their way into my permanent collection. I've also been appreciative of the feedback I've received, particularly from some of the creators behind the books I've discovered. Their comments have put a face to a name and serve as a reminder that every comic book begins as an idea . . . just like this project did over three months ago. Who knows what the next three months will bring? Who knows what challenges will befall the A Comic A Day challenge? In anticipation, I'll quote (or at least paraphrase, since I don't have it here in front of me) the last line from the first comic book I read this quarter, Ghostbusters #4: "Bring 'em on."
You said it, Ray.
Looking at the long list of comic books I've read since July, I'm struggling to define this experience thus far. As I'd hoped, the comic books I've sampled represent the diversity of the medium, from era to artist to genre. Fortunately, A Comic A Day began on the cusp of the San Diego Comic Con, which fueled this project for an entire month. However, with the intention of experiencing as wide a variety as possible, I have found some local sources of graphic goodness that I wouldn't have thought of before. Pawn shops, hobby shops, and antique stores have been reliable sources for obscure material in a pinch, especially as I venture into themed reviews, like this month's appropriate series of posts re: horror/supernatural comics. Of course, living in Southern California is an advantage in itself; I can't ride my bike without running over somebody's demo tape. Pop culture is celebrated here. If I lived in Oklahoma, who knows if I'd find such a selection?
Further, since A Comic A Day is an exercise in artistic interaction, I've decided that desperation is at the core of quality comic book creating. Up and coming artists are desperate to create something new, while established artists, most likely working on equally established titles or characters, are desperate to do something new, lest their critics accuse them of rehashing past stories, styles, and concepts. Perusing my list of entries, Virgin Comics, God the Dyslexic Dog, and Don't Eat the Electric Sheep are excellent examples of artists mining fresh concepts to produce a different kind of comic book, either culturally, spiritually, or existentially, respectively in these cases. On the other hand, issues like Superman #300, Zot! #29, and Invincible #1 are decent attempts at reestablishing the superhero as a relevant paradigm in fiction. Both categories boast their hits and misses, and I've already read them all. (I'm looking at you, Captain Paragon.) The question is, is art "good enough" as an attempt, or a successful effort?
The answer to that question defines the concept of art itself. Dim-witted Darryl may not have been my cup of tea, but I'm sure someone somewhere has fanatically collected every issue and is eagerly anticipating new material, if that series is still on the shelves today. What I look for in a comic book, what connects with me on a literary and/or artistic level, isn't going be in everyone else's tastes. Moreover, I may recognize a comic book as a legitimate effort, but an entertaining read doesn't always entail a commitment to a title. Sometimes, a glimpse is all we need. Who knows if Mona Lisa had a decent body? It's that smile we remember. It was good enough.
Most importantly, I'm enjoying this experience, and I'm grateful that some of these comic books that otherwise I never would have experienced have now made their way into my permanent collection. I've also been appreciative of the feedback I've received, particularly from some of the creators behind the books I've discovered. Their comments have put a face to a name and serve as a reminder that every comic book begins as an idea . . . just like this project did over three months ago. Who knows what the next three months will bring? Who knows what challenges will befall the A Comic A Day challenge? In anticipation, I'll quote (or at least paraphrase, since I don't have it here in front of me) the last line from the first comic book I read this quarter, Ghostbusters #4: "Bring 'em on."
You said it, Ray.
Monday, October 02, 2006
The Boys #1
The Boys #1, October 2006, Wildstorm Productions
writer: Garth Ennis
artist: Derick Robertson
colorist: Tony Avina
letterer: Greg Thompson
assistant editor: Kristy Quinn
editor: Ben Abernathy
That quarterly report will be on your desk first thing in the morning, Sir. I swear.
In the meantime, let's take a look at The Boys #1, another instant Garth Ennis classic, complete with its overt sex, violence, and middle-aged angst against the machine. In this case, "the machine" is the mainstream superhero genre. The Boys is about an under-the-table government-sanctioned group of superhero police. Apparently, they keep superheroes accountable for their recklessly violent actions, in turn by being recklessly violent, I presume. The first page of this series depicts the lead -- Butcher -- stomping on a wanna-be Captain America's face, an image that plays no other role in the issue but the offering of that shocking first impression, that "wow, this is gonna be a hard-hitting comic" sensation.
Still, I suspect that Ennis has an ulterior motive. See, there's a small but extremely popular faction of comic book writers that have expressed a blatant disgust for the superhero faction of their industry. Ennis and Warren Ellis are often the leaders of this pack. Hey, I don't blame them. If I worked at McDonald's and everybody only ordered a six-piece, I'd get bored and annoyed pretty quickly, too. When interviewed or journaling on the subject, these writers have always insisted that superhero fiction dominates their medium, and further, that the cookie-cut black and white morality of it all, coupled with the spandex-clad homoeroticism of these mindless slugfest-driven franchised epics, have dullened the impact comics can have as a forum for graphic sequential storytelling. (That's my synopsis, by the way.) Although I'm a fan of superheroes, fairly because they remind me of my carefree youth, I'd agree with them . . .
. . . if they didn't keep writing superhero comics. Preacher may have been an epic social commentary with spiritual, social, and political overtones, with smatterings of romance and western comics influence for good measure, but Jesse Custer was still brandishing a super power. He was a super hero. If Preacher was published sans controversial language and adult material, if the violence was just a little less so, and if the Vertigo label was replaced with the DC bullet, the series would have been a short-lived superhero title, plain and simple. Ellis's Transmetropolitan is arguably in the same genre of anti-capes comics, in the post-modern sense of the phrase. Spider Jerusalem didn't have any powers, but he had a well honed talent that he used to change the world for the better, as he perceived the concept. Basically, he was Frank Miller's Batman minus the training and long underwear, even so far as "adopting" a few female sidekicks along the way to proverbially dethroning the President (if only in a symbolic way, in Reagan's and Luthor's cases from Dark Knight Returns and Strikes Again).
And these are just their "magnum opus" titles, the series that they are best known for. Ellis and Ennis have both written bona fide superhero comics, on many occasions. Superheroes may be killing the comic book as an artform, but it's certainly good enough to put food on the table.
Don't get me wrong. I count Preacher and Transmet as two of my favorite finite books, and Ellis and Ennis are among my favorite writers, even if their respective styles have begun to parody themselves. Consider the other Ennis #1 I recently reviewed: A Man Called Kev #1. First issue, gratuitous sex and violence, but a few characters I'd like to get to know better. Same formula. And in the Boys' case, they've found an artist, Transmet's Robertson, that can depict the duality their dark but fantastic world expertly. He's been on both sides of the fence, too. He's mastered both.
Am I in for The Boys #2? Absolutely. But I hope Ennis' vague allegory begins to unravel into a genuinely complex piece of fiction, as I'd expect from him. What allegory, you ask? Well, whose boot was really stomping that cornfed captain on page one? Who's really trying to take superheroes to task here? Ellis pulled a similar stunt in Planetary, when Jerusalem appeared as the "new face of comics." Ennis is trying change the genre from the inside out. Let's see if he can save the day.
writer: Garth Ennis
artist: Derick Robertson
colorist: Tony Avina
letterer: Greg Thompson
assistant editor: Kristy Quinn
editor: Ben Abernathy
That quarterly report will be on your desk first thing in the morning, Sir. I swear.
In the meantime, let's take a look at The Boys #1, another instant Garth Ennis classic, complete with its overt sex, violence, and middle-aged angst against the machine. In this case, "the machine" is the mainstream superhero genre. The Boys is about an under-the-table government-sanctioned group of superhero police. Apparently, they keep superheroes accountable for their recklessly violent actions, in turn by being recklessly violent, I presume. The first page of this series depicts the lead -- Butcher -- stomping on a wanna-be Captain America's face, an image that plays no other role in the issue but the offering of that shocking first impression, that "wow, this is gonna be a hard-hitting comic" sensation.
Still, I suspect that Ennis has an ulterior motive. See, there's a small but extremely popular faction of comic book writers that have expressed a blatant disgust for the superhero faction of their industry. Ennis and Warren Ellis are often the leaders of this pack. Hey, I don't blame them. If I worked at McDonald's and everybody only ordered a six-piece, I'd get bored and annoyed pretty quickly, too. When interviewed or journaling on the subject, these writers have always insisted that superhero fiction dominates their medium, and further, that the cookie-cut black and white morality of it all, coupled with the spandex-clad homoeroticism of these mindless slugfest-driven franchised epics, have dullened the impact comics can have as a forum for graphic sequential storytelling. (That's my synopsis, by the way.) Although I'm a fan of superheroes, fairly because they remind me of my carefree youth, I'd agree with them . . .
. . . if they didn't keep writing superhero comics. Preacher may have been an epic social commentary with spiritual, social, and political overtones, with smatterings of romance and western comics influence for good measure, but Jesse Custer was still brandishing a super power. He was a super hero. If Preacher was published sans controversial language and adult material, if the violence was just a little less so, and if the Vertigo label was replaced with the DC bullet, the series would have been a short-lived superhero title, plain and simple. Ellis's Transmetropolitan is arguably in the same genre of anti-capes comics, in the post-modern sense of the phrase. Spider Jerusalem didn't have any powers, but he had a well honed talent that he used to change the world for the better, as he perceived the concept. Basically, he was Frank Miller's Batman minus the training and long underwear, even so far as "adopting" a few female sidekicks along the way to proverbially dethroning the President (if only in a symbolic way, in Reagan's and Luthor's cases from Dark Knight Returns and Strikes Again).
And these are just their "magnum opus" titles, the series that they are best known for. Ellis and Ennis have both written bona fide superhero comics, on many occasions. Superheroes may be killing the comic book as an artform, but it's certainly good enough to put food on the table.
Don't get me wrong. I count Preacher and Transmet as two of my favorite finite books, and Ellis and Ennis are among my favorite writers, even if their respective styles have begun to parody themselves. Consider the other Ennis #1 I recently reviewed: A Man Called Kev #1. First issue, gratuitous sex and violence, but a few characters I'd like to get to know better. Same formula. And in the Boys' case, they've found an artist, Transmet's Robertson, that can depict the duality their dark but fantastic world expertly. He's been on both sides of the fence, too. He's mastered both.
Am I in for The Boys #2? Absolutely. But I hope Ennis' vague allegory begins to unravel into a genuinely complex piece of fiction, as I'd expect from him. What allegory, you ask? Well, whose boot was really stomping that cornfed captain on page one? Who's really trying to take superheroes to task here? Ellis pulled a similar stunt in Planetary, when Jerusalem appeared as the "new face of comics." Ennis is trying change the genre from the inside out. Let's see if he can save the day.
Sunday, October 01, 2006
Ghostbusters #3
Ghostbusters #3, May 2004, 88MPH Studios
writer: Andrew Dobb
penciller: Steve Kurth
inkers: Steve LaPointe with Ulices Grostieto, Jimmy Reyes, and Marco Galli
letterer: Ed Dukeshire
colorist: Blond
editor: Sebastian Clavet
I’ve selected Ghostbusters as October’s first review, a conscious and intentional effort to celebrate this month’s hallowed holiday. (Consistent A Comic A Day readers may remember the trend of “spooky” comics that haunted last week’s offerings, a week too early for my tastes.) This issue, the last in a four-issue miniseries, has been on my list of must-reads for a while anyway, since I managed to purchase the third chapter when the mini was originally released. This series was difficult to find, a testament that the Ghostbusters franchise still has a loyal following. The Ghostbusters mythos, now over twenty-five years old, has undergone a few different incarnations since the treasured original film, including the equally respected original animated series, the blockbuster sequel, and, least successfully, the “next generation” cartoon/action figure attempt of the mid-‘90s. My first question is, did this miniseries re-launch the struggling franchise for yet another eager generation?
Sadly, no. Don’t get me wrong – I thoroughly enjoyed the two issues I read, and if I ever find the first two, or, even better, a trade with some behind-the-scenes extras. Alas, since this series flew off the shelves so quickly, either from a limited publication run, higher than usual orders, or both, Ghostbusters didn’t linger long enough for potential readers to obligatorily look into it. In other words, in my estimation, steadfast fans pinched the Ghostbusters comic book before anyone else, even casual fans like me. Fortunately, from what I remember, the series was too quietly released to garner the attention it really deserved. Had posters cluttered comic shop windows, I’m sure fans would’ve lined up the night before. Rioted in the streets for an original copy. You know. Mass hysteria.
As I was saying, I enjoyed this issue. Best summarized by in the inside front cover’s synopsis, “Michael Draverhaven – an old friend of Egon, Peter, and Ray’s driven mad by an experiment gone wrong – has emerged from years trapped in a mental institution with one thing on his mind: Revenge! Now, with an army of ghosts at his command, he plans to rain havoc on the city of New York . . . and the Ghostbusters!” This chapter picks up with Ray in Michael’s custody, while the madman uses tendrils of ectoplasm to control the ghosts in the others’ path. In a moment of rash desperation, Winston uses a duct-taped bundle of new wireless traps to create a hole in the wall of specters, and, triangulating Ray’s location with his cell phone, the gang crashes Draverhaven’s party. Ray struggles with his former friend and pushes him into some debris, which knocks Michael out, severs his link with the ghosts, and plunges him into a coma. The ghosts flee, and although the Ghostbusters seem uncharacteristically comfortable with so many specters still on the loose, they’re obviously grateful that the organized haunting is over.
I do not envy Andrew Dobb, the writer of this miniseries. The original film was one of the most popular and critically acclaimed of its time and remains one of the most successful comedies of all time. In fact, Ghostbusters may have created a new genre entirely – the haunted comedy. I still quote the film on a regular basis, and I know its dedicated fan base continue to discuss the franchise through fanfic and message boards. So, how do you follow Dan Ackroyd, Ivan Rietman, and Harold Ramis? First of all, you don’t try to be funny. Instead, you find and expose each characters’ core personality, the traits that made their original, successful live action and animated interactions so beloved. Peter is often misunderstood as blatantly sarcastic and pessimistic; however, in contrast with his friends’ wild ideas, conjectures, and adventures, Venkman is simply the most realistic guy in the bunch, reacting as most of us would, in suspended disbelief. Egon, the supposed brains, isn’t void of humor, and in fact his superior intellect instills in him a dry wit that implies a sense of superiority over the others. Consider this exchange, when Ray doesn’t pick up his phone:
PETER: No answer. Do you think something happened to him?
EGON: I think there’s a good chance he’s dead and this city will be nothing but rubble in less than twenty-four hours.
PETER: God, Egon, don’t say that. Lie to me. Tell me we’re going to get through this.
EGON: We’re going to get through this. And candy and teddy bears will rain from the sky.
PETER: There, was that so hard?
I can actually hear Ramis and Murray enacting this dialogue, or even the voice actors from the original cartoon. And although the narrative isn’t blatantly funny, a subtle humor infuses their relationship and runs throughout the rest of the issue. Well done.
Further, as a fan, I couldn’t help but notice that Dobb has decided to ignore continuity established in the original’s lesser sequel. A bold move. Ghostbusters II may not have been as funny, but it was still the brainchild of the franchise’s founding fathers, Ackroyd and Ramis. Still, by forsaking that installment, this story’s most charming moments remain possible, like when Louis awkwardly and futilely asks Peter to leave Dana alone, or when Janine blatantly asks Egon out, when all subtlety finally fails her. (In Ghostbusters II, Louis and Janine became an item, and Dana had a baby. I didn’t see little Oscar anywhere here.) Above all else, the whole gang is here, even a less comical Slimer, and with the Ecto-1 intact. I’m ready to believe them again.
Artistically, I don’t envy this issue’s artists, either. The decision whether or not to caricature the original actors, recreate the classic cartoon’s model sheets, or take different approach entirely could literally make or break the success of this series. Kurth (assuming he designed the characters for this incarnation) does a decent job creating a synthesis of the previous two looks while putting his own stamp on the characters; unfortunately, this issue suffers from an inconsistency in the inking department. The ghosts appear a little too tangible and humanoid, as well, a trapping of the original film’s resources that could have been creatively overcome today. Still, the issue is well drawn, and I hope the whole mini is this good. If so, no human being could stack books like this.
So what if this miniseries didn’t create full blown Ghostbusters renaissance? At least it thrust Peter, Ray, Egon, and Winston into the spotlight once again, especially for their adoring fans. I haven’t seen the ongoing series the end of this issue promises, but if it isn’t out yet, I hope we see it sooner or later. I wouldn’t want the Ghostbusters to become ghosts themselves. The Ghostbusters may have a tough exterior, in the face of danger, but inside they’re just as sweet as the marshmallow that covers them at the end of the first movie. I guess what I’m trying to say is, they’re like a bunch of big Twinkies.
What about the Twinkie?
writer: Andrew Dobb
penciller: Steve Kurth
inkers: Steve LaPointe with Ulices Grostieto, Jimmy Reyes, and Marco Galli
letterer: Ed Dukeshire
colorist: Blond
editor: Sebastian Clavet
I’ve selected Ghostbusters as October’s first review, a conscious and intentional effort to celebrate this month’s hallowed holiday. (Consistent A Comic A Day readers may remember the trend of “spooky” comics that haunted last week’s offerings, a week too early for my tastes.) This issue, the last in a four-issue miniseries, has been on my list of must-reads for a while anyway, since I managed to purchase the third chapter when the mini was originally released. This series was difficult to find, a testament that the Ghostbusters franchise still has a loyal following. The Ghostbusters mythos, now over twenty-five years old, has undergone a few different incarnations since the treasured original film, including the equally respected original animated series, the blockbuster sequel, and, least successfully, the “next generation” cartoon/action figure attempt of the mid-‘90s. My first question is, did this miniseries re-launch the struggling franchise for yet another eager generation?
Sadly, no. Don’t get me wrong – I thoroughly enjoyed the two issues I read, and if I ever find the first two, or, even better, a trade with some behind-the-scenes extras. Alas, since this series flew off the shelves so quickly, either from a limited publication run, higher than usual orders, or both, Ghostbusters didn’t linger long enough for potential readers to obligatorily look into it. In other words, in my estimation, steadfast fans pinched the Ghostbusters comic book before anyone else, even casual fans like me. Fortunately, from what I remember, the series was too quietly released to garner the attention it really deserved. Had posters cluttered comic shop windows, I’m sure fans would’ve lined up the night before. Rioted in the streets for an original copy. You know. Mass hysteria.
As I was saying, I enjoyed this issue. Best summarized by in the inside front cover’s synopsis, “Michael Draverhaven – an old friend of Egon, Peter, and Ray’s driven mad by an experiment gone wrong – has emerged from years trapped in a mental institution with one thing on his mind: Revenge! Now, with an army of ghosts at his command, he plans to rain havoc on the city of New York . . . and the Ghostbusters!” This chapter picks up with Ray in Michael’s custody, while the madman uses tendrils of ectoplasm to control the ghosts in the others’ path. In a moment of rash desperation, Winston uses a duct-taped bundle of new wireless traps to create a hole in the wall of specters, and, triangulating Ray’s location with his cell phone, the gang crashes Draverhaven’s party. Ray struggles with his former friend and pushes him into some debris, which knocks Michael out, severs his link with the ghosts, and plunges him into a coma. The ghosts flee, and although the Ghostbusters seem uncharacteristically comfortable with so many specters still on the loose, they’re obviously grateful that the organized haunting is over.
I do not envy Andrew Dobb, the writer of this miniseries. The original film was one of the most popular and critically acclaimed of its time and remains one of the most successful comedies of all time. In fact, Ghostbusters may have created a new genre entirely – the haunted comedy. I still quote the film on a regular basis, and I know its dedicated fan base continue to discuss the franchise through fanfic and message boards. So, how do you follow Dan Ackroyd, Ivan Rietman, and Harold Ramis? First of all, you don’t try to be funny. Instead, you find and expose each characters’ core personality, the traits that made their original, successful live action and animated interactions so beloved. Peter is often misunderstood as blatantly sarcastic and pessimistic; however, in contrast with his friends’ wild ideas, conjectures, and adventures, Venkman is simply the most realistic guy in the bunch, reacting as most of us would, in suspended disbelief. Egon, the supposed brains, isn’t void of humor, and in fact his superior intellect instills in him a dry wit that implies a sense of superiority over the others. Consider this exchange, when Ray doesn’t pick up his phone:
PETER: No answer. Do you think something happened to him?
EGON: I think there’s a good chance he’s dead and this city will be nothing but rubble in less than twenty-four hours.
PETER: God, Egon, don’t say that. Lie to me. Tell me we’re going to get through this.
EGON: We’re going to get through this. And candy and teddy bears will rain from the sky.
PETER: There, was that so hard?
I can actually hear Ramis and Murray enacting this dialogue, or even the voice actors from the original cartoon. And although the narrative isn’t blatantly funny, a subtle humor infuses their relationship and runs throughout the rest of the issue. Well done.
Further, as a fan, I couldn’t help but notice that Dobb has decided to ignore continuity established in the original’s lesser sequel. A bold move. Ghostbusters II may not have been as funny, but it was still the brainchild of the franchise’s founding fathers, Ackroyd and Ramis. Still, by forsaking that installment, this story’s most charming moments remain possible, like when Louis awkwardly and futilely asks Peter to leave Dana alone, or when Janine blatantly asks Egon out, when all subtlety finally fails her. (In Ghostbusters II, Louis and Janine became an item, and Dana had a baby. I didn’t see little Oscar anywhere here.) Above all else, the whole gang is here, even a less comical Slimer, and with the Ecto-1 intact. I’m ready to believe them again.
Artistically, I don’t envy this issue’s artists, either. The decision whether or not to caricature the original actors, recreate the classic cartoon’s model sheets, or take different approach entirely could literally make or break the success of this series. Kurth (assuming he designed the characters for this incarnation) does a decent job creating a synthesis of the previous two looks while putting his own stamp on the characters; unfortunately, this issue suffers from an inconsistency in the inking department. The ghosts appear a little too tangible and humanoid, as well, a trapping of the original film’s resources that could have been creatively overcome today. Still, the issue is well drawn, and I hope the whole mini is this good. If so, no human being could stack books like this.
So what if this miniseries didn’t create full blown Ghostbusters renaissance? At least it thrust Peter, Ray, Egon, and Winston into the spotlight once again, especially for their adoring fans. I haven’t seen the ongoing series the end of this issue promises, but if it isn’t out yet, I hope we see it sooner or later. I wouldn’t want the Ghostbusters to become ghosts themselves. The Ghostbusters may have a tough exterior, in the face of danger, but inside they’re just as sweet as the marshmallow that covers them at the end of the first movie. I guess what I’m trying to say is, they’re like a bunch of big Twinkies.
What about the Twinkie?
Saturday, September 30, 2006
Stan Lee Meets Spider-Man #1
Stan Lee Meets Spider-Man #1, November 2006, Marvel Comics
writers: Stan Lee, Joss Whedon, Fred Hembeck
artists: Olivier Coipel, Mark Morales, Michael Gaydos, Fred Hembeck, John Romita, Sr., & Jim Mooney
colorists: Jose Villarrubia, Pete Pantazis, Bill Crabtree
letterers: Dave Lanphear, Sam Rosen
Today, the last day of September, commemorates the one-fourth marks of the yearlong A Comics A Day challenge. I don’t want to waste valuable review space reflecting on the last three months – I intend to write a quarterly report in the next few days or so – but the anniversary is worth mentioning because today’s issue celebrates a comic book benchmark, as well: Stan Lee’s sixty-five years at Marvel. The first in a series of one-shots starring “the Man” himself, Stan Lee Meets Spider-man is a hilarious read, honoring one of the founding fathers of the modern superhero genre, featuring three original short stories and a reprint of Amazing Spider-man #87. Since each story retains an identity all its own, I’ll review each yarn separately, complete with respective plot synopses and reflections on their impact to the medium. In this case, the medium is Stan Lee.
The first yarn, written by Stan himself, is the issue’s title story, in which Spider-man swings by Stan’s pad with an usual case of the woe-is-me’s. Stan, who prior to Spidey’s unexpected arrival makes a verbal effort to announce that he has the house to himself for the evening, throws a batch of his patented superhero cookies in the oven and escorts ol’ Web-head to the den, where the Wallcrawler unwinds about the dastardly dangers of his determined do-goodery. I’ll confess, when Spidey turns to his cunningly cantankerous creator for a word of advice, I expected the comics veteran to spew forth a string of campy, old world wisdom, rife with allusions to the importance of being a role model and how, you guessed it, with great power comes great responsibility. A nice tidy tale with a friendly neighborhood moral about the importance of nobility and the relevance of comic books, right?
Say it ain’t so, true believers! We, and Spidey, hear nothing of the sort! Stan wags an accusing finger and proclaims, “If you quit, think of the people you’ll put out of business! The T-shirt manufacturers! The animation companies! The movie studios! The action figure makers! The comic book publishers! The video game designers! The poster artists! You’re not just a superhero, you’re a whole bunch’a industries! Single-handedly, you’re keeping our economy afloat!” Seemingly convicted, Spidey surprisingly accepts the call of duty again, and just when I think that Stan, as the writer, has lost his marbles, the final sequence of this silly tale reveals Spider-man rendezvousing with a second-stringer, Mosquito Man, on a nearby rooftop. “Stan talked me out of it,” ol’ Webhead says. “Damn! I thought I’d finally have a chance to take your place!” Mosquito Man laments. Are we to assume that Spidey and Stan staged their tête-à -tête to help ease the wounded ego of a C-list superhero?
Even if Stan’s franchise-centric soliloquy wasn’t sincere, I can attest to its truthfulness, not only as a fan that scours the toy shelves for the latest action figure offerings, but also as a resident of Southern California that often finds himself in the seediest swap meets around Los Angeles. In fact, just before I read this issue, my galpal and I browsed L.A.’s popular fashion district, which is as rife with fake designer clothing as it is homemade Spider-man toys, school supplies, and peculiar paraphernalia, from baby mittens to steering wheel covers. Those white slits followed me around every corner I turned today! So, as usual, Stan couldn’t have said it better himself. Hilariously, by patting Spidey on the back, Stan is actually stroking his own ego, proclaiming his (rightful) place as the padre of the pop culture marketplace. Hey, if you want the title, Stan, you can have it!
Now, I don’t know who Steve Ennitz is, but Joss Whedon does, and in the second story, not one, not two, but four incarnations of this Ennitz character appear, meeting one another at an interdimensional comicon to discuss the industry from their respective worlds. The Steve from our world is surprised to discover a lack of superheroics in the other dimensions, as the chuckle-worthy covers of The Normal Four, and Amazing Reality reveal. When their conversation becomes a frenzied debate, our Steve cites “the Man” as the topmost source for super-powered prose, to the blank stares of his other-selves. Apparently, our dimension is the only tier of reality with its own Stan Lee! A frustrated Steve-1 eventually finds Stan on the convention floor, who proudly claims, “Well, there’s a lot of amazing comic creators in the multiverse, kid . . . But there’s only one Stan Lee.” Then, another Stan Lee swaggers up from behind and says, “I’m a Stan Lee. I sell meats.” Nice.
Whedon’s wry humor is downright delicious in this diatribe. Further, the casual close encounter with Stan is reminiscent of his cameo in Kevin Smith’s Mallrats, which is always a favorable reference. But I understand what Whedon was trying to say. Without Stan, characters like the Fantastic Four and Spider-man still could have been inspired by superhero boom spun off from National Publications’ popular Justice League concept. They could still exist. Alas, they wouldn’t have been as colorful, entertaining, or successful. Creators like Whedon, or collectors like this Steve Ennitz fellow, may not have been as passionate about the medium if not for Lee’s enthusiastic persona. They’d still be fans, but not with as much vigor. Stan Lee didn’t just change the industry from behind the typewriter; he changed the way readers read comics.
I don’t know who Fred Hembeck is, either, but in is offering to this issue, he recreates himself as a cartoon character alongside some lesser known Marvel properties, like the Beetle and Percival Pinkerton from Nick Fury’s Howling Commandos, just to stand in line for a chance to meet their marvelous maker. The two-page strip is a funny Bullpen style in-joke comic for diehard fans of Marvel Comics. Unfortunately, I am not one of them. Can’t wait ‘em all.
Finally, this issue wraps with a Stan Lee original, a classic ASM tale called “Unmasked At Last!” In this Romita-rific yarn, poor Peter Parker is inexplicably losing his powers, and apparently more tragically, he has no one to confide in without exposing his secret identity. To make matters worse, his fragility prevents him from arriving at Gwen’s birthday party on time, and when he finally stumbles through the door, he desperately reveals that he is Spider-man! When his weakness persists, Spidey rushes himself to the hospital where, in the most anticlimactic twist in Marvel history, I’m sure, Spider-man is diagnosed with . . . the flu! More uncannily, the knowledge of his ailment is evidently its own cure, as ol’ Webhead springs to his feet and successfully devises a plain to clear his name with his friends. I must admit, if this tale was a new release in today’s critical market, readers would eat this issue alive. Although Spider-man’s worst enemy is ironically himself, the plot is so full of holes that it redefines the Bronze Age’s concept of cheese! At the same time, I wouldn’t be surprised if Stan was the first to coin a concept like this, in which with great power comes great fatigue. We’ve seen every iconic superhero hang up the mask before, but in this case, Spidey nearly sacrificed the sanctity of every aspect of his life. In the end, he came out on top. Stan may have put all of his characters, especially Spider-man, through the ringer, but, as this story bears witness, he never completely abandoned them.
This entire issue is proof of that, despite his scarcity in the spotlight lately, despite the failed projects and desperate comicon appearances, Stan Lee is still the king of comicdom. His contributions have shaped the industry single-handed. Are there any other modern media that can attribute so much of its success to one man? Personally, I remember watching the Stan Lee interview conducted by Kevin Smith that was included in the special Spider-man DVD package. To ask Stan where many of his creations came from, to ask him to recall the muse that visited him in those early days, is to watch an old man’s eyes squint in strained remembrance, is to watch a clever writer come up with an answer to appease his faithful audience. Not “my editor told me to come up with some colorful characters or else,” or “I’m an old man, how am I supposed to remember?” Further proof that Stan Lee is the master of his own fate. If he wants to meet his own characters, maybe again for the first time, who are we to say otherwise?
With its diverse short stories, Stan Lee Meets Spider-Man is a solid synopsis of my three-month passage into this project – I connected with one, was confused by another, and completely alienated by another. The classic Spider-man tale was a pleasant reminder of the innocent way things used to be, of the times when a reader took the fantastic elements of a story at face value. I can only hope that the inevitable commemoration of the A Comic A Day challenge can be so perfectly packaged. Stay tuned for my quarterly report. Ninety-two comics down. Two hundred and seventy-three to go.
writers: Stan Lee, Joss Whedon, Fred Hembeck
artists: Olivier Coipel, Mark Morales, Michael Gaydos, Fred Hembeck, John Romita, Sr., & Jim Mooney
colorists: Jose Villarrubia, Pete Pantazis, Bill Crabtree
letterers: Dave Lanphear, Sam Rosen
Today, the last day of September, commemorates the one-fourth marks of the yearlong A Comics A Day challenge. I don’t want to waste valuable review space reflecting on the last three months – I intend to write a quarterly report in the next few days or so – but the anniversary is worth mentioning because today’s issue celebrates a comic book benchmark, as well: Stan Lee’s sixty-five years at Marvel. The first in a series of one-shots starring “the Man” himself, Stan Lee Meets Spider-man is a hilarious read, honoring one of the founding fathers of the modern superhero genre, featuring three original short stories and a reprint of Amazing Spider-man #87. Since each story retains an identity all its own, I’ll review each yarn separately, complete with respective plot synopses and reflections on their impact to the medium. In this case, the medium is Stan Lee.
The first yarn, written by Stan himself, is the issue’s title story, in which Spider-man swings by Stan’s pad with an usual case of the woe-is-me’s. Stan, who prior to Spidey’s unexpected arrival makes a verbal effort to announce that he has the house to himself for the evening, throws a batch of his patented superhero cookies in the oven and escorts ol’ Web-head to the den, where the Wallcrawler unwinds about the dastardly dangers of his determined do-goodery. I’ll confess, when Spidey turns to his cunningly cantankerous creator for a word of advice, I expected the comics veteran to spew forth a string of campy, old world wisdom, rife with allusions to the importance of being a role model and how, you guessed it, with great power comes great responsibility. A nice tidy tale with a friendly neighborhood moral about the importance of nobility and the relevance of comic books, right?
Say it ain’t so, true believers! We, and Spidey, hear nothing of the sort! Stan wags an accusing finger and proclaims, “If you quit, think of the people you’ll put out of business! The T-shirt manufacturers! The animation companies! The movie studios! The action figure makers! The comic book publishers! The video game designers! The poster artists! You’re not just a superhero, you’re a whole bunch’a industries! Single-handedly, you’re keeping our economy afloat!” Seemingly convicted, Spidey surprisingly accepts the call of duty again, and just when I think that Stan, as the writer, has lost his marbles, the final sequence of this silly tale reveals Spider-man rendezvousing with a second-stringer, Mosquito Man, on a nearby rooftop. “Stan talked me out of it,” ol’ Webhead says. “Damn! I thought I’d finally have a chance to take your place!” Mosquito Man laments. Are we to assume that Spidey and Stan staged their tête-à -tête to help ease the wounded ego of a C-list superhero?
Even if Stan’s franchise-centric soliloquy wasn’t sincere, I can attest to its truthfulness, not only as a fan that scours the toy shelves for the latest action figure offerings, but also as a resident of Southern California that often finds himself in the seediest swap meets around Los Angeles. In fact, just before I read this issue, my galpal and I browsed L.A.’s popular fashion district, which is as rife with fake designer clothing as it is homemade Spider-man toys, school supplies, and peculiar paraphernalia, from baby mittens to steering wheel covers. Those white slits followed me around every corner I turned today! So, as usual, Stan couldn’t have said it better himself. Hilariously, by patting Spidey on the back, Stan is actually stroking his own ego, proclaiming his (rightful) place as the padre of the pop culture marketplace. Hey, if you want the title, Stan, you can have it!
Now, I don’t know who Steve Ennitz is, but Joss Whedon does, and in the second story, not one, not two, but four incarnations of this Ennitz character appear, meeting one another at an interdimensional comicon to discuss the industry from their respective worlds. The Steve from our world is surprised to discover a lack of superheroics in the other dimensions, as the chuckle-worthy covers of The Normal Four, and Amazing Reality reveal. When their conversation becomes a frenzied debate, our Steve cites “the Man” as the topmost source for super-powered prose, to the blank stares of his other-selves. Apparently, our dimension is the only tier of reality with its own Stan Lee! A frustrated Steve-1 eventually finds Stan on the convention floor, who proudly claims, “Well, there’s a lot of amazing comic creators in the multiverse, kid . . . But there’s only one Stan Lee.” Then, another Stan Lee swaggers up from behind and says, “I’m a Stan Lee. I sell meats.” Nice.
Whedon’s wry humor is downright delicious in this diatribe. Further, the casual close encounter with Stan is reminiscent of his cameo in Kevin Smith’s Mallrats, which is always a favorable reference. But I understand what Whedon was trying to say. Without Stan, characters like the Fantastic Four and Spider-man still could have been inspired by superhero boom spun off from National Publications’ popular Justice League concept. They could still exist. Alas, they wouldn’t have been as colorful, entertaining, or successful. Creators like Whedon, or collectors like this Steve Ennitz fellow, may not have been as passionate about the medium if not for Lee’s enthusiastic persona. They’d still be fans, but not with as much vigor. Stan Lee didn’t just change the industry from behind the typewriter; he changed the way readers read comics.
I don’t know who Fred Hembeck is, either, but in is offering to this issue, he recreates himself as a cartoon character alongside some lesser known Marvel properties, like the Beetle and Percival Pinkerton from Nick Fury’s Howling Commandos, just to stand in line for a chance to meet their marvelous maker. The two-page strip is a funny Bullpen style in-joke comic for diehard fans of Marvel Comics. Unfortunately, I am not one of them. Can’t wait ‘em all.
Finally, this issue wraps with a Stan Lee original, a classic ASM tale called “Unmasked At Last!” In this Romita-rific yarn, poor Peter Parker is inexplicably losing his powers, and apparently more tragically, he has no one to confide in without exposing his secret identity. To make matters worse, his fragility prevents him from arriving at Gwen’s birthday party on time, and when he finally stumbles through the door, he desperately reveals that he is Spider-man! When his weakness persists, Spidey rushes himself to the hospital where, in the most anticlimactic twist in Marvel history, I’m sure, Spider-man is diagnosed with . . . the flu! More uncannily, the knowledge of his ailment is evidently its own cure, as ol’ Webhead springs to his feet and successfully devises a plain to clear his name with his friends. I must admit, if this tale was a new release in today’s critical market, readers would eat this issue alive. Although Spider-man’s worst enemy is ironically himself, the plot is so full of holes that it redefines the Bronze Age’s concept of cheese! At the same time, I wouldn’t be surprised if Stan was the first to coin a concept like this, in which with great power comes great fatigue. We’ve seen every iconic superhero hang up the mask before, but in this case, Spidey nearly sacrificed the sanctity of every aspect of his life. In the end, he came out on top. Stan may have put all of his characters, especially Spider-man, through the ringer, but, as this story bears witness, he never completely abandoned them.
This entire issue is proof of that, despite his scarcity in the spotlight lately, despite the failed projects and desperate comicon appearances, Stan Lee is still the king of comicdom. His contributions have shaped the industry single-handed. Are there any other modern media that can attribute so much of its success to one man? Personally, I remember watching the Stan Lee interview conducted by Kevin Smith that was included in the special Spider-man DVD package. To ask Stan where many of his creations came from, to ask him to recall the muse that visited him in those early days, is to watch an old man’s eyes squint in strained remembrance, is to watch a clever writer come up with an answer to appease his faithful audience. Not “my editor told me to come up with some colorful characters or else,” or “I’m an old man, how am I supposed to remember?” Further proof that Stan Lee is the master of his own fate. If he wants to meet his own characters, maybe again for the first time, who are we to say otherwise?
With its diverse short stories, Stan Lee Meets Spider-Man is a solid synopsis of my three-month passage into this project – I connected with one, was confused by another, and completely alienated by another. The classic Spider-man tale was a pleasant reminder of the innocent way things used to be, of the times when a reader took the fantastic elements of a story at face value. I can only hope that the inevitable commemoration of the A Comic A Day challenge can be so perfectly packaged. Stay tuned for my quarterly report. Ninety-two comics down. Two hundred and seventy-three to go.
Friday, September 29, 2006
El Cazador #2
El Cazador #2, November 2003, CrossGen Comics
writer: Chuck Dixon
artist: Steve Epting
colorist: Frank Darmata
letterer: Dave Lanphear
Pirates are in. Thanks to the success of the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, this Halloween will undoubtedly see a rise in pirate costume sails . . . I mean sales. It's shame Chuck Dixon was a year or two behind the times with El Cazador. This pirate adventure would've met the market with potentially profitable results.
I didn't intend to review two Dixon books this week, but the contrast of El Cazador with Rush City is an excellent example of his versatility as a writer. His books are never too meaty, but they offer just enough character and action to leave the reader with a satisfying comic book experience every time. Of course, I'm sure there are others who would be quick to disagree, but Dixon's 100-issue run on Robin (not counting mini-series and annuals) reveals his commitment to his craft, how every issue he produces is a precursor for the next ambitious project.
And yes, El Cazador strikes me as an ambitious project. Could you sell a comic about pirates pre-Depp, especially when the word "pirates" doesn't even appear in the title? El Cazador is the pirate ship in this series, which has come under the recent leadership of a female captain. As you can imagine, many of the mates don't take this transition lightly, and in this installment, they attempt a mutiny. Fortunately, Lady Sin (that's her pirate name) has been trained in the ways of the sword, and she has retained the faithfulness of enough of her crew to maintain her position. Now, this is but an aspect of the story, which has something to do with, what else, the search for a forbidden land, but as a stand-alone chapter, this issue stands up. I could've done without the Spanish one-liners, though. You're not impressing me with your Spanish textbook glossary, okay, Chuck?
Visually? I loved it. Can't think of a better way for this book to have been illustrated. Anything more stylized than Epting's capable pencils would've turned the issue into a farce. The characters were expressive and distinctive, the backgrounds were finely detailed without overwhelming any given panel, and thanks to the coloring as well, the mood was well established and maintained. I hope this creative team was onboard for the breadth of the series.
CrossGen should get this series into trade paperbacks as soon as possible, if they haven't already, lest they miss the wave of pirate popularity presently plundering our pop culture. I'm sure Dixon, Epting, and company could rake in plenty of retro-booty. Isn't that the best kind?
writer: Chuck Dixon
artist: Steve Epting
colorist: Frank Darmata
letterer: Dave Lanphear
Pirates are in. Thanks to the success of the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, this Halloween will undoubtedly see a rise in pirate costume sails . . . I mean sales. It's shame Chuck Dixon was a year or two behind the times with El Cazador. This pirate adventure would've met the market with potentially profitable results.
I didn't intend to review two Dixon books this week, but the contrast of El Cazador with Rush City is an excellent example of his versatility as a writer. His books are never too meaty, but they offer just enough character and action to leave the reader with a satisfying comic book experience every time. Of course, I'm sure there are others who would be quick to disagree, but Dixon's 100-issue run on Robin (not counting mini-series and annuals) reveals his commitment to his craft, how every issue he produces is a precursor for the next ambitious project.
And yes, El Cazador strikes me as an ambitious project. Could you sell a comic about pirates pre-Depp, especially when the word "pirates" doesn't even appear in the title? El Cazador is the pirate ship in this series, which has come under the recent leadership of a female captain. As you can imagine, many of the mates don't take this transition lightly, and in this installment, they attempt a mutiny. Fortunately, Lady Sin (that's her pirate name) has been trained in the ways of the sword, and she has retained the faithfulness of enough of her crew to maintain her position. Now, this is but an aspect of the story, which has something to do with, what else, the search for a forbidden land, but as a stand-alone chapter, this issue stands up. I could've done without the Spanish one-liners, though. You're not impressing me with your Spanish textbook glossary, okay, Chuck?
Visually? I loved it. Can't think of a better way for this book to have been illustrated. Anything more stylized than Epting's capable pencils would've turned the issue into a farce. The characters were expressive and distinctive, the backgrounds were finely detailed without overwhelming any given panel, and thanks to the coloring as well, the mood was well established and maintained. I hope this creative team was onboard for the breadth of the series.
CrossGen should get this series into trade paperbacks as soon as possible, if they haven't already, lest they miss the wave of pirate popularity presently plundering our pop culture. I'm sure Dixon, Epting, and company could rake in plenty of retro-booty. Isn't that the best kind?
Thursday, September 28, 2006
Lone Wolf 2100 #2
Lone Wolf 2100 #2, June 2002, Dark Horse Comics
writer: Mike Kennedy
artist: Francisco Ruiz Velasco
additional coloring: Edgar Delgado
letterer: Chris Horn
assistant editor: Jeremy Barlow
editor: Randy Stradley
Inspired by the classic manga series Lone Wolf and Cub by Kazuo Koine and Goseki Kojima.
When I began planning the A Comic A Day challenge back in June, I told myself, “A year is a long time. You’re going to review a different comic book you’ve never read before every day? Even on your birthday? On Christmas? What if somebody dies? Will you review a comic book that day, too?” Unfortunately, the latter came first. I eulogized my old friend on my LiveJournal, but I will reiterate here that he was a tech guy, a freelance computer technician. Interestingly, today’s read is about futuristic rogue technology. The parallel hasn’t escaped me.
Lone Wolf 2100 is, of course, inspired by Lone Wolf and Cub, the fan favorite manga series. (I’ve recently read that even Frank Miller, who has contributed covers to the series, is a diehard fan himself.) I’ve never read the original, and in fact I thought that this issue was a part of that earlier series, so I’m disappointed that I essentially unwittingly purchased a spin-off, and further, that I don’t have a point of reference to compare it to its hallowed predecessor.
Then again, maybe that’s a good thing, because I rather enjoyed this issue. “Lone Wolf” is the renegade Itto, an android emulation construct (Emcon) apparently built for battle, and “Cub” is his former master’s infant daughter. Together, they are on the run, when this installment begins, the two have taken refuge in a tormented but isolated village. Before he hits the road again, Itto swiftly defeats the village’s oppressors by severing several of their extremities with a mere swipe of his hand. The band’s leader catches up with Itto and although the warrior bests many of the desert thugs, he is still vulnerable to a bullet in the back. The tyrants take the baby and Itto ends up back at the village, where despite the simpletons’ skepticism of his nobility, the android gets back on-line and back on his feet to vow that he will rescue the wayward cub. In the meantime, a fellow Emcon aligns with the government to find Itto and the child. To be continued.
Despite his rigidity, Itto is a likeable character and a believable hero. He has masterful combat skills but is obviously not invincible. He has an allegiance to his liege in spite of his programming, and he apparently inspires opposition from the wicked and faithfulness from the pure of heart. Kennedy paces this story well, with the interludes finely woven into the main feature’s momentum. This may be the second chapter in a four-part tale, but it stands alone as a compelling adventure with dynamic characters in its own right. Velasco has a manga style to his adaptation, but the characters’ blocking is definitely Western, combing the best of both worlds. These pages look like scanned pencils, and although I may be wrong, this rough element coupled with some moody, pastel coloring make for a genuine engrossing experience. The lack of backgrounds on several pages is an afterthought. The concept’s depth is good enough.
So will combat-ready androids conquer the world in a mere one hundred years, roaming the countryside with some warped samurai code? In this incarnation, Lone Wolf is Ronin-meets-Terminator, an interesting combination, and one that suspends belief. Comic books are always good for that. In the face of loss, of reality, a little escapism never hurt anybody.
writer: Mike Kennedy
artist: Francisco Ruiz Velasco
additional coloring: Edgar Delgado
letterer: Chris Horn
assistant editor: Jeremy Barlow
editor: Randy Stradley
Inspired by the classic manga series Lone Wolf and Cub by Kazuo Koine and Goseki Kojima.
When I began planning the A Comic A Day challenge back in June, I told myself, “A year is a long time. You’re going to review a different comic book you’ve never read before every day? Even on your birthday? On Christmas? What if somebody dies? Will you review a comic book that day, too?” Unfortunately, the latter came first. I eulogized my old friend on my LiveJournal, but I will reiterate here that he was a tech guy, a freelance computer technician. Interestingly, today’s read is about futuristic rogue technology. The parallel hasn’t escaped me.
Lone Wolf 2100 is, of course, inspired by Lone Wolf and Cub, the fan favorite manga series. (I’ve recently read that even Frank Miller, who has contributed covers to the series, is a diehard fan himself.) I’ve never read the original, and in fact I thought that this issue was a part of that earlier series, so I’m disappointed that I essentially unwittingly purchased a spin-off, and further, that I don’t have a point of reference to compare it to its hallowed predecessor.
Then again, maybe that’s a good thing, because I rather enjoyed this issue. “Lone Wolf” is the renegade Itto, an android emulation construct (Emcon) apparently built for battle, and “Cub” is his former master’s infant daughter. Together, they are on the run, when this installment begins, the two have taken refuge in a tormented but isolated village. Before he hits the road again, Itto swiftly defeats the village’s oppressors by severing several of their extremities with a mere swipe of his hand. The band’s leader catches up with Itto and although the warrior bests many of the desert thugs, he is still vulnerable to a bullet in the back. The tyrants take the baby and Itto ends up back at the village, where despite the simpletons’ skepticism of his nobility, the android gets back on-line and back on his feet to vow that he will rescue the wayward cub. In the meantime, a fellow Emcon aligns with the government to find Itto and the child. To be continued.
Despite his rigidity, Itto is a likeable character and a believable hero. He has masterful combat skills but is obviously not invincible. He has an allegiance to his liege in spite of his programming, and he apparently inspires opposition from the wicked and faithfulness from the pure of heart. Kennedy paces this story well, with the interludes finely woven into the main feature’s momentum. This may be the second chapter in a four-part tale, but it stands alone as a compelling adventure with dynamic characters in its own right. Velasco has a manga style to his adaptation, but the characters’ blocking is definitely Western, combing the best of both worlds. These pages look like scanned pencils, and although I may be wrong, this rough element coupled with some moody, pastel coloring make for a genuine engrossing experience. The lack of backgrounds on several pages is an afterthought. The concept’s depth is good enough.
So will combat-ready androids conquer the world in a mere one hundred years, roaming the countryside with some warped samurai code? In this incarnation, Lone Wolf is Ronin-meets-Terminator, an interesting combination, and one that suspends belief. Comic books are always good for that. In the face of loss, of reality, a little escapism never hurt anybody.
Wednesday, September 27, 2006
A Man Called Kev #1
A Man Called Kev #1, September 2006, Wildstorm Productions
writer: Garth Ennis
artist: Carlos Ezquerra
colorist: David Baron
letterer: Phil Balsman
assists: Kristy Quinn
editor: Ben Abernathy
When I first read Garth Ennis’ opus Preacher, I lived and breathed by its satiric, macabre doctrine. As a comic book series, I was overwhelmingly impressed by Ennis’ ability to establish outrageous but sympathetic characters – predictable archetypes with vulnerable twists that made them charming and compelling. As a piece of literature, I was intrigued by the book’s spiritual perspectives, from deistic creatures like the Saint of Killers wandering our countryside to the concept of a tuck-and-run God that flees at the first sign of trouble. Preacher was a modern myth laced rife with religion, politics, pop culture, and most importantly, inspiration. Ennis obviously compiled his adoration of various genres of fiction with his pressing thoughts on existence, and I was completely swept away. After I devoured the nine volume series, I sought other Ennis material . . .
. . . and I have been consistently disappointed. Just A Pilgrim and The Adventures in the Rifle Brigade were too tongue-in-cheek for my tastes. The characters didn’t elicit my compassion like Custer, Tulip, and company did. The stories weren’t as insightful, as meaningful. His Punisher stuff I’ve read has been entertaining, but again, I didn’t sense the enthusiasm with Frank’s pursuits that Ennis exuded in his Vertigo hit. I’ve wondered if Ennis blew his wad on Preacher.
I know Garth has a more expansive library than what I’ve read, with more projects on the horizon, which is why I picked up A Man Called Kev. With such a flippant title, I expected Ennis’ usual sophomoric violence, sexual deviancy, and crude language, the elements that have driven a wedge between his entire career and my teetering devotion. Opening the issue, I thought, “Is Ennis really the one-trick pony I’ve assumed, or will he convict me with another series?” My answer?
I don’t know. I didn’t realize that A Man Called Kev has strong ties to Ennis’ The Authority arc, that the series is essentially a spin-off starring, what I assume was, a secondary character. In this first issue, Kevin, a mercenary of sorts, I reckon, is blackmailed by her Majesty’s government to leave the country, lest his political crimes catch up to him. Kev’s friend Bob, a writer that shares an interlude about his getting drunk at a party and mimicking a monkey and while swinging nude on a chandelier “accidentally” stuck his you-know-what in some debutante’s agape mouth, suggests a refuge with their old tiger-taming friend in San Francisco. Bob is later killed by a mysterious band of hitmen inexplicably on Kev’s trial, which explains why four of this issue’s pages were dedicated to his strange confession – we were supposed to feel for his loss, I suppose. Maybe this is why I feel so disconnected with Ennis’ work – Preacher was a 66 issue series with several supporting minis, which is plenty of space to play with the depths of an ensemble cast of diverse characters. Now, Ennis works in four issues here, five issues there. He tries to accomplish in a matter of pages what once built for succession of stories. Maybe Ennis needs to practice what he preached.
I’ve never been taken by Ezquerra’s artwork, but I enjoyed it in A Man Called Kev. His characters are expressive and dramatic, with a natural posture that reflects the tale’s strange sense of humor and that powder keg of paranoia soon to explode in future issues. Although Ennis tends to wax poetic but obviously respects his artist by offering a variety of scenes, but a bloody shootout to a hoity-toity publishers’ party rife with colorful, visually amusing players. I’m sure as an artist, a script from Ennis is an adventure to illustrate in and of itself.
A Man Called Kev may be the first series I pursue as a result of the A Comics A Day challenge. I want to see where Ennis takes this one. Will we plunge into a character study of a man at a crossroads, with a new life awaiting him, or will we wander aimlessly through another sex-and-guns romp, a popcorn comic bloated with its own entertaining shock value? One is called a comic worth reading. The other I don’t bother to call at all.
writer: Garth Ennis
artist: Carlos Ezquerra
colorist: David Baron
letterer: Phil Balsman
assists: Kristy Quinn
editor: Ben Abernathy
When I first read Garth Ennis’ opus Preacher, I lived and breathed by its satiric, macabre doctrine. As a comic book series, I was overwhelmingly impressed by Ennis’ ability to establish outrageous but sympathetic characters – predictable archetypes with vulnerable twists that made them charming and compelling. As a piece of literature, I was intrigued by the book’s spiritual perspectives, from deistic creatures like the Saint of Killers wandering our countryside to the concept of a tuck-and-run God that flees at the first sign of trouble. Preacher was a modern myth laced rife with religion, politics, pop culture, and most importantly, inspiration. Ennis obviously compiled his adoration of various genres of fiction with his pressing thoughts on existence, and I was completely swept away. After I devoured the nine volume series, I sought other Ennis material . . .
. . . and I have been consistently disappointed. Just A Pilgrim and The Adventures in the Rifle Brigade were too tongue-in-cheek for my tastes. The characters didn’t elicit my compassion like Custer, Tulip, and company did. The stories weren’t as insightful, as meaningful. His Punisher stuff I’ve read has been entertaining, but again, I didn’t sense the enthusiasm with Frank’s pursuits that Ennis exuded in his Vertigo hit. I’ve wondered if Ennis blew his wad on Preacher.
I know Garth has a more expansive library than what I’ve read, with more projects on the horizon, which is why I picked up A Man Called Kev. With such a flippant title, I expected Ennis’ usual sophomoric violence, sexual deviancy, and crude language, the elements that have driven a wedge between his entire career and my teetering devotion. Opening the issue, I thought, “Is Ennis really the one-trick pony I’ve assumed, or will he convict me with another series?” My answer?
I don’t know. I didn’t realize that A Man Called Kev has strong ties to Ennis’ The Authority arc, that the series is essentially a spin-off starring, what I assume was, a secondary character. In this first issue, Kevin, a mercenary of sorts, I reckon, is blackmailed by her Majesty’s government to leave the country, lest his political crimes catch up to him. Kev’s friend Bob, a writer that shares an interlude about his getting drunk at a party and mimicking a monkey and while swinging nude on a chandelier “accidentally” stuck his you-know-what in some debutante’s agape mouth, suggests a refuge with their old tiger-taming friend in San Francisco. Bob is later killed by a mysterious band of hitmen inexplicably on Kev’s trial, which explains why four of this issue’s pages were dedicated to his strange confession – we were supposed to feel for his loss, I suppose. Maybe this is why I feel so disconnected with Ennis’ work – Preacher was a 66 issue series with several supporting minis, which is plenty of space to play with the depths of an ensemble cast of diverse characters. Now, Ennis works in four issues here, five issues there. He tries to accomplish in a matter of pages what once built for succession of stories. Maybe Ennis needs to practice what he preached.
I’ve never been taken by Ezquerra’s artwork, but I enjoyed it in A Man Called Kev. His characters are expressive and dramatic, with a natural posture that reflects the tale’s strange sense of humor and that powder keg of paranoia soon to explode in future issues. Although Ennis tends to wax poetic but obviously respects his artist by offering a variety of scenes, but a bloody shootout to a hoity-toity publishers’ party rife with colorful, visually amusing players. I’m sure as an artist, a script from Ennis is an adventure to illustrate in and of itself.
A Man Called Kev may be the first series I pursue as a result of the A Comics A Day challenge. I want to see where Ennis takes this one. Will we plunge into a character study of a man at a crossroads, with a new life awaiting him, or will we wander aimlessly through another sex-and-guns romp, a popcorn comic bloated with its own entertaining shock value? One is called a comic worth reading. The other I don’t bother to call at all.
Tuesday, September 26, 2006
Rush City #1
Rush City #1, September 2006, DC Comics
writer: Chuck Dixon
artist: Timothy Green II
colorist: Jose Villarrubia
letterer: Travis Lanham
editors: Ron Perazza & Bill Rosemann
Fall is upon us, and the television networks are throwing new series are us, the vulnerable viewing audience, to which will stick for more than a season. From what I've observed, we have some shows about shows, offering an exclusive behind-the-scenes perspective of the personal dramas that must unfold to make decent television in the first place, and I must not forget about the compelling hour-long dramas, as well, like Vanished or Smith, which draw us into the seedy but attractive underbelly of organized crime. Rush City reads like one of these premieres, pitching us a high-end idea that, depending on us, could become the next big hit . . . or a flop.
Dixon's Rush City has some potential. "Rush" is a bounty hunter of sorts, tracking down folks that others simply don't want to find. In the first issue, he's on the trail of a missing little girl with diabetes that was lost in the thick of pedestrian traffic on the subway, and who the police won't investigate until she's missing for the token twenty-four hours. Raising to get the girl her next insulin shot, Rush digs through the underground to a body parts peddler, who gives her up because "Nobody'll buy parts from a sick kid." Sick. Dixon almost goes too far in revealing the city's darkest depths, and the length Rush will go to rescue her from it. Rush must have some criminal past, as well, because his mission is frequently interrupted by a band of rogue policemen. Interesting. Since he finds the girl, that must be our draw into the next issue. If this subplot doesn't play into the lead character's origins or overall pursuit for the missing, it's an unnecessary element that takes valuable page space from the series' real intrigue. This is why the series has some potential, but it may become its worst enemy.
I didn't even think about it until the end, when I read the "next issue" blurb, but a Black Canary appearance teaser reveals that Rush City has ties with the rest of the DCU. As interesting as it is to think that a world where people can see through walls and run around the globe in an eyeblink needs a man like Rush, Dixon has given me another reason to shy away from the series. I love 'em, but it doesn't always have to be about superheroes, man. A fast paced urban drama is good enough.
I was pleasantly surprised by Timothy Green's visuals. His attention to detail made for an intriguing "Where's Waldo?" of depravity, especially on page three, the splash where Rush pulls up to meet his distraught client. On the sidewalk, plain as day, we see a gun, a knife, and a crossbow arrow, as if such litter is as common as the Starbucks cup and cigarette butts that are also obvious. I did experience a disconnect with his characters' expressions, especially the moment where the lost girl's mother comments that her daughter must be in fear. The mother is smiling. I don't know if Green was suggesting that the mother was reflecting upon her daughter's resourcefulness with a subtle fondness, but it made the entire concept of the story fairly unbelievable. I was wondering if I missed something. Did the mother set Rush up? For an over-thinking reader like me, the simple panel added a level to the issue that wasn't even there. Again, Green's art was good, but perhaps its own detractor in those fine details.
Will I pick up the next issue? The bottom line is, I liked this one more than I didn't, and I'm interested in seeing where Dixon can take us next. So, yes, I will read it, and I'd better hop to it, as it's already on the stands. Let's see what a second impression has in store. After all, I wouldn't want to rush to judgment.
writer: Chuck Dixon
artist: Timothy Green II
colorist: Jose Villarrubia
letterer: Travis Lanham
editors: Ron Perazza & Bill Rosemann
Fall is upon us, and the television networks are throwing new series are us, the vulnerable viewing audience, to which will stick for more than a season. From what I've observed, we have some shows about shows, offering an exclusive behind-the-scenes perspective of the personal dramas that must unfold to make decent television in the first place, and I must not forget about the compelling hour-long dramas, as well, like Vanished or Smith, which draw us into the seedy but attractive underbelly of organized crime. Rush City reads like one of these premieres, pitching us a high-end idea that, depending on us, could become the next big hit . . . or a flop.
Dixon's Rush City has some potential. "Rush" is a bounty hunter of sorts, tracking down folks that others simply don't want to find. In the first issue, he's on the trail of a missing little girl with diabetes that was lost in the thick of pedestrian traffic on the subway, and who the police won't investigate until she's missing for the token twenty-four hours. Raising to get the girl her next insulin shot, Rush digs through the underground to a body parts peddler, who gives her up because "Nobody'll buy parts from a sick kid." Sick. Dixon almost goes too far in revealing the city's darkest depths, and the length Rush will go to rescue her from it. Rush must have some criminal past, as well, because his mission is frequently interrupted by a band of rogue policemen. Interesting. Since he finds the girl, that must be our draw into the next issue. If this subplot doesn't play into the lead character's origins or overall pursuit for the missing, it's an unnecessary element that takes valuable page space from the series' real intrigue. This is why the series has some potential, but it may become its worst enemy.
I didn't even think about it until the end, when I read the "next issue" blurb, but a Black Canary appearance teaser reveals that Rush City has ties with the rest of the DCU. As interesting as it is to think that a world where people can see through walls and run around the globe in an eyeblink needs a man like Rush, Dixon has given me another reason to shy away from the series. I love 'em, but it doesn't always have to be about superheroes, man. A fast paced urban drama is good enough.
I was pleasantly surprised by Timothy Green's visuals. His attention to detail made for an intriguing "Where's Waldo?" of depravity, especially on page three, the splash where Rush pulls up to meet his distraught client. On the sidewalk, plain as day, we see a gun, a knife, and a crossbow arrow, as if such litter is as common as the Starbucks cup and cigarette butts that are also obvious. I did experience a disconnect with his characters' expressions, especially the moment where the lost girl's mother comments that her daughter must be in fear. The mother is smiling. I don't know if Green was suggesting that the mother was reflecting upon her daughter's resourcefulness with a subtle fondness, but it made the entire concept of the story fairly unbelievable. I was wondering if I missed something. Did the mother set Rush up? For an over-thinking reader like me, the simple panel added a level to the issue that wasn't even there. Again, Green's art was good, but perhaps its own detractor in those fine details.
Will I pick up the next issue? The bottom line is, I liked this one more than I didn't, and I'm interested in seeing where Dixon can take us next. So, yes, I will read it, and I'd better hop to it, as it's already on the stands. Let's see what a second impression has in store. After all, I wouldn't want to rush to judgment.
Monday, September 25, 2006
Gene-Fusion A.D. 2310 #3
Gene-Fusion A.D. 2310 #3 (vol. 2), May 2003, Beckett Comics
writer: Ivan Brandon
penciller: Neil Vokes
inker: Jay Geldhof
letterer: Ken Bruzenak
color art director: Matt Hollingsworth
colorist: Giulia Brusco
Gene-Fusion A.D. 2310. I don’t get it.
As a fifteen-year fan and student of the comic book as a medium of entertainment and sequential art, I feel like I’ve made a connection with every issue I’ve ever read. Even the most terribly written, most poorly illustrated issue has offered something to my general study of “the comic,” if only to demonstrate how the implementation of the craft is least effective. Or, if an issue is well written and beautifully drawn, but its content or genre isn’t my personal cup of tea, I can usually find an image or a scrap of dialogue that made the read worthwhile. Consider The Nevermen. I made the mistake of reading the mini’s last issue, which was too rife with backstory to stand alone, but even in the thick of plot’s momentum, I discovered a line or two of dialogue that intrigued me – that drew me in, if only for a moment. This is art – overcoming the preconceptions of style, time, and context to connect with the participant. The unique interactive nature of the comic book, from turning the page to following the visual panel-to-panel sequence, simply speaks to me.
Gene-Fusion A.D. 2310 barely whispered in my ear. I couldn’t find that moment, which was, as you can imagine, incredibly frustrating. This issue began with the Gene Fusion team (?) defeating a fusimal, some sort of bull, zebra, lion hybrid. Then, they seek respite in an old style saloon, where the miniscule Ethan is selected to fight in a caged fusion battle – whatever that means. The heroes’ dialogue strikes me as an eager writer’s attempt to purge these characters’ concepts from his mind, and the interplay between two sets of characters is too back-and-forth for me to invest in either one of them. The artwork volleys between a poor Bruce Timm imitation and a rushed attempt to mimic mainstream American manga, and neither really works. The coloring is too unnecessarily vibrant to offer a variant in mood throughout the topsy-turvy story, holding the reader at arm’s length. I just didn’t get what this title was trying to accomplish. The only part I really understood was the penultimate twist, pitting the helpless Ethan in a ring with one of those inexplicable, ferocious fusimals for sport.
That’s it! Despite the violent results, the evil ringleaders of Ethan’s fusimal match are simply cheap entertainment peddlers, like Tina Turner in Beyond Thunderdome, and in an odd stretch of the imagination, my quest to connect with comic books is similar to their futuristic rodeo. I’m on the hunt for amusement! The quest for entertainment! For me, since an early age, comic books have been my art of choice. Maybe in three hundred and four years, bull/zebra/lion grappling will float my great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-grandson’s boat. Art may not come in forms we understand, and Lord knows there are plenty of folks that don’t understand comics, but its purpose is still the same.
And you read that realization in real time, folks. When I began this review, I really had no idea where it was going to go. I usually do. I made that connection in retrospect, through analysis, which is what the A Comic A Day challenge is about. You saw it happen here. An association. A fusion.
writer: Ivan Brandon
penciller: Neil Vokes
inker: Jay Geldhof
letterer: Ken Bruzenak
color art director: Matt Hollingsworth
colorist: Giulia Brusco
Gene-Fusion A.D. 2310. I don’t get it.
As a fifteen-year fan and student of the comic book as a medium of entertainment and sequential art, I feel like I’ve made a connection with every issue I’ve ever read. Even the most terribly written, most poorly illustrated issue has offered something to my general study of “the comic,” if only to demonstrate how the implementation of the craft is least effective. Or, if an issue is well written and beautifully drawn, but its content or genre isn’t my personal cup of tea, I can usually find an image or a scrap of dialogue that made the read worthwhile. Consider The Nevermen. I made the mistake of reading the mini’s last issue, which was too rife with backstory to stand alone, but even in the thick of plot’s momentum, I discovered a line or two of dialogue that intrigued me – that drew me in, if only for a moment. This is art – overcoming the preconceptions of style, time, and context to connect with the participant. The unique interactive nature of the comic book, from turning the page to following the visual panel-to-panel sequence, simply speaks to me.
Gene-Fusion A.D. 2310 barely whispered in my ear. I couldn’t find that moment, which was, as you can imagine, incredibly frustrating. This issue began with the Gene Fusion team (?) defeating a fusimal, some sort of bull, zebra, lion hybrid. Then, they seek respite in an old style saloon, where the miniscule Ethan is selected to fight in a caged fusion battle – whatever that means. The heroes’ dialogue strikes me as an eager writer’s attempt to purge these characters’ concepts from his mind, and the interplay between two sets of characters is too back-and-forth for me to invest in either one of them. The artwork volleys between a poor Bruce Timm imitation and a rushed attempt to mimic mainstream American manga, and neither really works. The coloring is too unnecessarily vibrant to offer a variant in mood throughout the topsy-turvy story, holding the reader at arm’s length. I just didn’t get what this title was trying to accomplish. The only part I really understood was the penultimate twist, pitting the helpless Ethan in a ring with one of those inexplicable, ferocious fusimals for sport.
That’s it! Despite the violent results, the evil ringleaders of Ethan’s fusimal match are simply cheap entertainment peddlers, like Tina Turner in Beyond Thunderdome, and in an odd stretch of the imagination, my quest to connect with comic books is similar to their futuristic rodeo. I’m on the hunt for amusement! The quest for entertainment! For me, since an early age, comic books have been my art of choice. Maybe in three hundred and four years, bull/zebra/lion grappling will float my great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-grandson’s boat. Art may not come in forms we understand, and Lord knows there are plenty of folks that don’t understand comics, but its purpose is still the same.
And you read that realization in real time, folks. When I began this review, I really had no idea where it was going to go. I usually do. I made that connection in retrospect, through analysis, which is what the A Comic A Day challenge is about. You saw it happen here. An association. A fusion.
Sunday, September 24, 2006
On the Far Side With Dead Folks #3
On the Far Side With Dead Folks #3, June 2003, Avatar Press
writer: Joe R. Lansdale (based on his story On the Far Side of the Cadillac Desert With Dead Folks)
artist: Timothy Truman
editor in chief: William Christensen
creative director: Mark Seifert
I swear, Halloween is taunting me. I can't go to the store without buying some creepy little trinket, and I can't read two comics without coming across some witch, ghost, or goblin. The Darkness was possessed. The Naoki Urasawa sampler was haunted. Even the lead tale from Wednesday's Looney Tunes issue featured a mad scientist and the lovable big red monster Gossamer. Today's offering, On the Far Side With Dead Folks, is strictly a zombie story. I wonder if I'll find a graphic novel or two featuring turkeys come Thanksgiving.
I assume Dead Folks #3 is the last of a three issue mini, because its ending is quite Shakespearean, if you know what I mean. If you don't, (spoiler alert) everybody dies, and by everybody, I mean the three characters we follow for a harrowing sixteen page escape from the clutches of a bloodthirsty pack of zombies holed up in some amusement park in the middle of an otherwise vast, vacant desert. (No, it's not Magic Mountain, but that's a good guess.) Interestingly, these wayward heroes don't destroy the undead denizens, other than the ones diligently pursuing them. They don't kill the head zombie which in turn destroys all the zombies, as many stories like this go. Unless I completely missed something, the humans simply flee with their lives, which seems good enough for them . . .
. . . except for when the girl turns out not to be a human, and after one of the men mercifully kills her, he guns down the other, a lowlife by the name of Calhoun, in a good old-fashioned shoot out. A scrap of narrative reveals that Calhoun has a bounty on his head, but apparently the reward doesn't matter in the end, because the bounty hunter offs himself, as well. The title of this series, which is the best part of the book if you ask me, should be Nothing BUT Dead Folks, 'cause that's what we're left with, when all's said and done. I don't get it, but I suppose that's what the the two issues before this episode are for. Sometimes we readers take the whole "here's what happened last time" shtick for granted.
Timothy Truman is a fine artist, but his work in this issue doesn't pack the horrific punch that a zombie chase would normally entail. The issue's stunning lack of color or even grayscale is a definite detractor; with such a beautifully rendered cover, I expected more illustrative depth from the interior. Understandably, Truman's focus may have been on the suspense and momentum of the heroes' fast-paced pursuit, wherein the macabre nature of the zombie army falls somewhat by the wayside. With an airplane crash and a car chase with a big rig in the mix, he definitely has plenty else to work with. They can't all be Thriller, I suppose.
I'll confess a curiosity about the short story from which this series was based, but it's a mild one. I can't imagine how this installment would've read sans pictures, since the whole zombies-on-our-tails thing is a very visual concept. Plus, without the context of the whole story, I really don't know where this "far side" is. I'd like to know. With Halloween popping up everywhere else in my life of late, the "far side" is the last place I need to end up.
writer: Joe R. Lansdale (based on his story On the Far Side of the Cadillac Desert With Dead Folks)
artist: Timothy Truman
editor in chief: William Christensen
creative director: Mark Seifert
I swear, Halloween is taunting me. I can't go to the store without buying some creepy little trinket, and I can't read two comics without coming across some witch, ghost, or goblin. The Darkness was possessed. The Naoki Urasawa sampler was haunted. Even the lead tale from Wednesday's Looney Tunes issue featured a mad scientist and the lovable big red monster Gossamer. Today's offering, On the Far Side With Dead Folks, is strictly a zombie story. I wonder if I'll find a graphic novel or two featuring turkeys come Thanksgiving.
I assume Dead Folks #3 is the last of a three issue mini, because its ending is quite Shakespearean, if you know what I mean. If you don't, (spoiler alert) everybody dies, and by everybody, I mean the three characters we follow for a harrowing sixteen page escape from the clutches of a bloodthirsty pack of zombies holed up in some amusement park in the middle of an otherwise vast, vacant desert. (No, it's not Magic Mountain, but that's a good guess.) Interestingly, these wayward heroes don't destroy the undead denizens, other than the ones diligently pursuing them. They don't kill the head zombie which in turn destroys all the zombies, as many stories like this go. Unless I completely missed something, the humans simply flee with their lives, which seems good enough for them . . .
. . . except for when the girl turns out not to be a human, and after one of the men mercifully kills her, he guns down the other, a lowlife by the name of Calhoun, in a good old-fashioned shoot out. A scrap of narrative reveals that Calhoun has a bounty on his head, but apparently the reward doesn't matter in the end, because the bounty hunter offs himself, as well. The title of this series, which is the best part of the book if you ask me, should be Nothing BUT Dead Folks, 'cause that's what we're left with, when all's said and done. I don't get it, but I suppose that's what the the two issues before this episode are for. Sometimes we readers take the whole "here's what happened last time" shtick for granted.
Timothy Truman is a fine artist, but his work in this issue doesn't pack the horrific punch that a zombie chase would normally entail. The issue's stunning lack of color or even grayscale is a definite detractor; with such a beautifully rendered cover, I expected more illustrative depth from the interior. Understandably, Truman's focus may have been on the suspense and momentum of the heroes' fast-paced pursuit, wherein the macabre nature of the zombie army falls somewhat by the wayside. With an airplane crash and a car chase with a big rig in the mix, he definitely has plenty else to work with. They can't all be Thriller, I suppose.
I'll confess a curiosity about the short story from which this series was based, but it's a mild one. I can't imagine how this installment would've read sans pictures, since the whole zombies-on-our-tails thing is a very visual concept. Plus, without the context of the whole story, I really don't know where this "far side" is. I'd like to know. With Halloween popping up everywhere else in my life of late, the "far side" is the last place I need to end up.
Saturday, September 23, 2006
Mr. T #1
Mr. T #1, May 2005, AP Comics
writer: Chris Bunting
penciller: Neil Edwards
inker: Randy Emberlin
colorist: Don MacKinnon
letterer: Richard Emms
editor: Rick Bumston
Avid readers of my blogs (Hi, Mom!) know that I have been faithfully watching The A-Team on the Sleuth Network for the past few months. Two episodes air daily, at 1 a.m. and 3 a.m. PST, and again throughout the day while I’m at work, so I usually record them – I’m still operating pre-TiVo – and watch them when I come home. George Peppard is my new hero, but I admire the entire cast, especially the tireless Mr. T. Somewhere in my bedroom closet at my mom’s house I have a Mr. T action figure, and sometimes when I burp I can still taste the famous Mr. T cereal from my childhood. So, you can imagine my excitement when I found a Mr. T comic book at the shop earlier this afternoon. At $3.75, just a quarter above its original cover price, this issue was the most expensive book I’ve purchased in awhile, but by far the most priceless in the sentimental department.
All that said, I wish the issue actually delivered more Mr. T. In this story, our urban hero is in seclusion after doing some time for a crime he didn’t commit, and he’s apparently given up on pitying the fools. An old friend, a doctor torn between the threats of a drug-dealing mob and its young, ailing victims, solicits the T to come out of retirement to expose and defeat the peddlers; this convicting conversation is the whole of issue #1. I understand that the writer, no doubt a diehard fan of Mr. T as well, is trying to build anticipation for the big T’s premiere action-packed appearance, but when I turned to the last page – a splash of Mr. T out of the shadows for the first time in twenty-two pages, his fist cocked back, ready to throw down – I was disappointed that I’d have to pick up the next ish for a true taste of some exciting fist-T-cuffs. In any given episode of The A-Team, you’re guaranteed a token toss-a-crook-over-a-car scene before the end of the first act!
An interlude of thought: I wonder if the writer intended to pick up where Mr. T’s campy cartoon series left off. Where else would Mr. T have a reputation as an urban do-gooder, unless future issues feature flashbacks aplenty of a heretofore unseen continuity? Do I smell a Mr. T: Year One on the horizon?
Visually, this issue was lacking the solidity that a well-known character like Mr. T is due. The problem may have been in the inking. Randy Emberlin, who I fondly remember from his critically acclaimed work over Larsen’s and Bagley’s pencils on The Amazing Spider-man, turns in a sub-par effort, with lines so thick that details look muddied, and with characters so heavily inked that some pages look like work I’ve seen in promotional comics of products, department stores, or nonprofit public service causes (i.e. “Wal-Mart Presents Spider-man Defeats Mysterio with Twinkies and Reminds the Kids to Say No to Drugs!”). Since Mr. T dwells in the shadows for most of the issue, undoubtedly so his appearance on the final splash page would pack more of a punch (pardon the pun), the inconsistent illustration didn’t affect his caricature too much – another disappointing reason why I’d have to pursue another issue. More than what the story entails, I want to see Mr. T in action!
Interlude #2: Is Mr. T the comic book based on, or inspired by, Mr. T the real, gold-wearing person? I originally typed “based on,” but since I’ve never heard a news story about the T beating up drug-dealing punks in the streets, I assume he is more of an inspiration, based on the positive messages he’s promoted. Just like I think 8 Mile is more “inspired by” than “based on” Eminem’s rise to power in rapdom. A needless thought, perhaps, but one that has struck me in the context of a comic involving such a well-known celebrity. This is caricature, as I said before, rather than biography.
Speaking of caricature, I’m reminded of the celebrity-as-fiction phenomenon that I briefly discussed in my review of Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen #141, featuring Don Rickles. Now, Don Rickles was a hero in concept only – hilarious insults don’t count as a superpower. In this case, I’m thinking of the larger than life celebrities that have actually boasted an image akin to a comic book hero, like Mr. T, Sgt. Slaughter, or one of my current favorites, Dog the Bounty Hunter (who deserves his own comic book, too, if you ask me). In their prime, these celebrities pitched feel good, kid-friendly morals, positioning them for cross-medium opportunities, like Mr. T’s cartoons, comics, and cereals, or Sgt. Slaughter’s involvement with the G.I. Joe crew. The problem is, celebrities like this must maintain a high standard of morality in order to assure the stability of their success. Consider the recent controversial arrest of Dog and his bounty hunting pack. Or what if Mr. T ever really did time for a crime he didn’t commit? These comics would be worthless in the face of his tarnished reputation. Don’t believe me? Do you think TV Land will air an episode of Berretta any time soon? Blake was found innocent in criminal court . . .
Fortunately, Mr. T is the type of static celebrity that has stood the test of time and maintained an image of integrity, even if it is only a character he has stuck with for nearly three whole decades. In fact, speaking of TV Land, Mr. T has apparently scored his own reality show, in which he actually pities fools. No joke. Frankly, I’m looking forward to seeing the T on TV again. I haven’t caught all five seasons’ worth of A-Team reruns yet, but that is a finite goal. (And I am still on the prowl for an A-Team comic book, if anyone can help.) I can rest assured that Mr. T isn’t finished with us yet. You can pity us when he finally decides to throw in the towel. Yes, pity us then.
writer: Chris Bunting
penciller: Neil Edwards
inker: Randy Emberlin
colorist: Don MacKinnon
letterer: Richard Emms
editor: Rick Bumston
Avid readers of my blogs (Hi, Mom!) know that I have been faithfully watching The A-Team on the Sleuth Network for the past few months. Two episodes air daily, at 1 a.m. and 3 a.m. PST, and again throughout the day while I’m at work, so I usually record them – I’m still operating pre-TiVo – and watch them when I come home. George Peppard is my new hero, but I admire the entire cast, especially the tireless Mr. T. Somewhere in my bedroom closet at my mom’s house I have a Mr. T action figure, and sometimes when I burp I can still taste the famous Mr. T cereal from my childhood. So, you can imagine my excitement when I found a Mr. T comic book at the shop earlier this afternoon. At $3.75, just a quarter above its original cover price, this issue was the most expensive book I’ve purchased in awhile, but by far the most priceless in the sentimental department.
All that said, I wish the issue actually delivered more Mr. T. In this story, our urban hero is in seclusion after doing some time for a crime he didn’t commit, and he’s apparently given up on pitying the fools. An old friend, a doctor torn between the threats of a drug-dealing mob and its young, ailing victims, solicits the T to come out of retirement to expose and defeat the peddlers; this convicting conversation is the whole of issue #1. I understand that the writer, no doubt a diehard fan of Mr. T as well, is trying to build anticipation for the big T’s premiere action-packed appearance, but when I turned to the last page – a splash of Mr. T out of the shadows for the first time in twenty-two pages, his fist cocked back, ready to throw down – I was disappointed that I’d have to pick up the next ish for a true taste of some exciting fist-T-cuffs. In any given episode of The A-Team, you’re guaranteed a token toss-a-crook-over-a-car scene before the end of the first act!
An interlude of thought: I wonder if the writer intended to pick up where Mr. T’s campy cartoon series left off. Where else would Mr. T have a reputation as an urban do-gooder, unless future issues feature flashbacks aplenty of a heretofore unseen continuity? Do I smell a Mr. T: Year One on the horizon?
Visually, this issue was lacking the solidity that a well-known character like Mr. T is due. The problem may have been in the inking. Randy Emberlin, who I fondly remember from his critically acclaimed work over Larsen’s and Bagley’s pencils on The Amazing Spider-man, turns in a sub-par effort, with lines so thick that details look muddied, and with characters so heavily inked that some pages look like work I’ve seen in promotional comics of products, department stores, or nonprofit public service causes (i.e. “Wal-Mart Presents Spider-man Defeats Mysterio with Twinkies and Reminds the Kids to Say No to Drugs!”). Since Mr. T dwells in the shadows for most of the issue, undoubtedly so his appearance on the final splash page would pack more of a punch (pardon the pun), the inconsistent illustration didn’t affect his caricature too much – another disappointing reason why I’d have to pursue another issue. More than what the story entails, I want to see Mr. T in action!
Interlude #2: Is Mr. T the comic book based on, or inspired by, Mr. T the real, gold-wearing person? I originally typed “based on,” but since I’ve never heard a news story about the T beating up drug-dealing punks in the streets, I assume he is more of an inspiration, based on the positive messages he’s promoted. Just like I think 8 Mile is more “inspired by” than “based on” Eminem’s rise to power in rapdom. A needless thought, perhaps, but one that has struck me in the context of a comic involving such a well-known celebrity. This is caricature, as I said before, rather than biography.
Speaking of caricature, I’m reminded of the celebrity-as-fiction phenomenon that I briefly discussed in my review of Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen #141, featuring Don Rickles. Now, Don Rickles was a hero in concept only – hilarious insults don’t count as a superpower. In this case, I’m thinking of the larger than life celebrities that have actually boasted an image akin to a comic book hero, like Mr. T, Sgt. Slaughter, or one of my current favorites, Dog the Bounty Hunter (who deserves his own comic book, too, if you ask me). In their prime, these celebrities pitched feel good, kid-friendly morals, positioning them for cross-medium opportunities, like Mr. T’s cartoons, comics, and cereals, or Sgt. Slaughter’s involvement with the G.I. Joe crew. The problem is, celebrities like this must maintain a high standard of morality in order to assure the stability of their success. Consider the recent controversial arrest of Dog and his bounty hunting pack. Or what if Mr. T ever really did time for a crime he didn’t commit? These comics would be worthless in the face of his tarnished reputation. Don’t believe me? Do you think TV Land will air an episode of Berretta any time soon? Blake was found innocent in criminal court . . .
Fortunately, Mr. T is the type of static celebrity that has stood the test of time and maintained an image of integrity, even if it is only a character he has stuck with for nearly three whole decades. In fact, speaking of TV Land, Mr. T has apparently scored his own reality show, in which he actually pities fools. No joke. Frankly, I’m looking forward to seeing the T on TV again. I haven’t caught all five seasons’ worth of A-Team reruns yet, but that is a finite goal. (And I am still on the prowl for an A-Team comic book, if anyone can help.) I can rest assured that Mr. T isn’t finished with us yet. You can pity us when he finally decides to throw in the towel. Yes, pity us then.
Friday, September 22, 2006
The Darkness #1
The Darkness #1 (vol. 2), May 2006, Image Comics
writer: Paul Jenkins
penciller: Dale Keown
colorist: Matt Milla
letterers: Dream Design's Robin Spehar & Dennis Heisler
Halloween is over a month away, but I've already seen more ghosts and goblins to last a lifetime. See, I'm an avid department store shopper, from Big Lots to Wal-Mart to Target. I visit each of those stores at least once a week, and since the end of August, the Halloween paraphernalia has flooded the marketplace like the steam from a witch's bubbling cauldron. It's everywhere.
I suppose that's why I didn't mind the abhorrent imagery of The Darkness. I don't mean the issue was illustrated poorly. In fact, this is my first close encounter of the Keown kind since PITT, and I must say, I didn't think the guy could get any better, but he did. He's abandoned the trappings of that mid-'90s fanfare, like the superfluous muscle veins or crosshatched under brow. The Darkness is has a fluidity to it, from the form of its characters to the layout of the page, and since the credits don't include an inker, I can only assume what we see is a high resolution scan of Keown's original pencils. Very impressive.
No, the abhorrent imagery is in the writing. This first issue is actually of the title's second volume, so Jenkins spends a considerable amount of page space catching us up on past events. Since I've never read The Darkness before, I was grateful for the recap, but I dare say that Jenkins wasted too much space with unnecessary narrative, especially considering his flagrant use of the hero's first person dialect. More dialogue would've offered more insight from more characters, like the mob stooges that plague the plot with their tireless cliches of hubris and vengeance. Not that the lead character is any less shallow, but at least he's honest. Yes, The Darkness is about a man's inner demons, but inasmuch as they literally take form, some can only conquered from the inside.
The Darkness strikes me as an excellent Halloween read, and when October actually arrives, I hope to unearth more macabre comic book tales, especially some Charlton titles from the '50s and '60s. Anything pre-Comics Code would be a treat, as well. In the meantime, titles like this will have to do. And they do. I'm glad I read The Darkness with the lights on.
writer: Paul Jenkins
penciller: Dale Keown
colorist: Matt Milla
letterers: Dream Design's Robin Spehar & Dennis Heisler
Halloween is over a month away, but I've already seen more ghosts and goblins to last a lifetime. See, I'm an avid department store shopper, from Big Lots to Wal-Mart to Target. I visit each of those stores at least once a week, and since the end of August, the Halloween paraphernalia has flooded the marketplace like the steam from a witch's bubbling cauldron. It's everywhere.
I suppose that's why I didn't mind the abhorrent imagery of The Darkness. I don't mean the issue was illustrated poorly. In fact, this is my first close encounter of the Keown kind since PITT, and I must say, I didn't think the guy could get any better, but he did. He's abandoned the trappings of that mid-'90s fanfare, like the superfluous muscle veins or crosshatched under brow. The Darkness is has a fluidity to it, from the form of its characters to the layout of the page, and since the credits don't include an inker, I can only assume what we see is a high resolution scan of Keown's original pencils. Very impressive.
No, the abhorrent imagery is in the writing. This first issue is actually of the title's second volume, so Jenkins spends a considerable amount of page space catching us up on past events. Since I've never read The Darkness before, I was grateful for the recap, but I dare say that Jenkins wasted too much space with unnecessary narrative, especially considering his flagrant use of the hero's first person dialect. More dialogue would've offered more insight from more characters, like the mob stooges that plague the plot with their tireless cliches of hubris and vengeance. Not that the lead character is any less shallow, but at least he's honest. Yes, The Darkness is about a man's inner demons, but inasmuch as they literally take form, some can only conquered from the inside.
The Darkness strikes me as an excellent Halloween read, and when October actually arrives, I hope to unearth more macabre comic book tales, especially some Charlton titles from the '50s and '60s. Anything pre-Comics Code would be a treat, as well. In the meantime, titles like this will have to do. And they do. I'm glad I read The Darkness with the lights on.
Thursday, September 21, 2006
JLA: Classified #26
JLA: Classified #26, October 2006, DC Comics
writer: Howard Chaykin
artists: Kilian Plunkett & Tom Nguyen
letterer: Ken Lopez
colorist: I.L.L.
editors: Palmer & Carlin
In my humble opinion, the Justice League titles should be the best mainstream superhero comic books on the market today. Where else can new readers find the most popular, iconic heroes of the our generation in a single adventure, and where else should veteran readers turn when they long to behold old characters tackling new and greater challenges on a regular basis? The diversity of the heroes' powers, personalities, and predicaments should make for the best action, adventure, and melodrama available in the medium, bar none. I'm not just talking about the "big seven," either -- the canon of characters popularized as a group in Grant Morrison's JLA relaunch. His run may have cemented my dedication to the team, but I've always admired DC's eclectic roster, and I think the "rotating chair" concept is one that benefits the League on a functional and fictional level, as a crime-fighting task force and a driving force in graphic literature. Bottom line, the Justice League isn't just one particular incarnation or collection of superheroes. It's DC Comics' chance to really show off their chops.
Unfortunately, DC doesn't know how to corral the horses in their stable. Like a painter cursed with perfectionism forever touching up his masterpiece, DC's canon has been revamped, repackaged, and relaunched so many times that the characters' cumulative effort, the League itself, often suffers from comic book crib death. The last ongoing JLA title, for example, lasted a mere 125 issues before the latest crisis pressed the proverbial restart button on the DCU. Before the end, the League went through three different Green Lanterns, if you count Hal Jordan's return in the eleventh hour. In retrospect, until the '80s, readers could pick up any issue of any DC title with little concern about cosmic continuity. Sure, some issues didn't make sense in the context of previous story arcs, including the existence of Earths ad infinitum, but the entertainment factor often overshadowed any potential confusion. Our heroes' adventures were fun. The Justice League was fun. Now, with a new line-up on the horizon, I don't trust the title. The series that I most looked forward to makes me cringe at the thought of how long (or, how short) it will last this time.
Enter JLA: Classified. A series dedicated to JL adventures from the past, these tales by rotating creative teams are free of all that baggage. Further, since the stories are essentially stand-alone mini-series, readers can come and go from the book depending on their tastes. I picked up the Ellis/Guise arc and took a break for a bit; now, I'm back for "Sacred Trust," a six-issue commitment that, if following installments live up to the first one, I can live with. Written by Chaykin, no stranger to a superhero tale with political intrigue, "Sacred Trust" begins with the League essentially disobeying the UN's warning to ignore two warring Middle Eastern countries, each building a metahuman army. More so than the snapshots of action, the driving force behind this yarn is the relationship between the heroes; as a diplomat himself, Aquaman insists that the League honor the UN's position, but Batman refuses as his fight for justice is accountable to no single government. Even Superman insists, "As a visitor to this planet, my loyalties are to its people, not its governing bodies." The League does shed their spandex to go undercover as civilians, so the next chapter should offer an interesting take on how their secret identities can be used for or against their favor. Looks the League likes to take leave of its baggage, too, from time to time.
Of course, the ideas presented in this arc are not new. In JLA, we saw the League fight as their civilian selves in the Mark Waid story that physically separated the heroes from their secret identities. And in "Golden Perfect," the League controversially tackled the troubles of a sovereign nation. Still, this is the group at its finest, slightly at odds with one another, which makes them human, but nevertheless divided for justice, which makes them heroes. No matter what else may happen to these characters, at least that will never change.
(Don't remind me about Parallax, okay?)
You know, without the Justice League, Marvel Comics as we know it may never have sprung forth from the mind of Stan Lee. The League's success inspired Lee's editor to prod Stan into creating their very own super-team, and the Fantastic Four was born. I'm sure you can find a more accurate history lesson somewhere on-line, but those are the essential facts. DC has always set the stage for the medium's concept of superhero fiction: from Batman: Year One came Spider-man: Chapter One. From Crisis on Infinite Earths came The Infinity Gaunlet. And this is just on the DC versus Marvel scale; other publishers have demonstrated similar trends. Believe me. Their characters just didn't have the history to stand up to the burden of such epic storytelling. Again, DC proves that their roster simply has the chops. Like everything else, the Justice League has overcome it. Even if it's classified.
writer: Howard Chaykin
artists: Kilian Plunkett & Tom Nguyen
letterer: Ken Lopez
colorist: I.L.L.
editors: Palmer & Carlin
In my humble opinion, the Justice League titles should be the best mainstream superhero comic books on the market today. Where else can new readers find the most popular, iconic heroes of the our generation in a single adventure, and where else should veteran readers turn when they long to behold old characters tackling new and greater challenges on a regular basis? The diversity of the heroes' powers, personalities, and predicaments should make for the best action, adventure, and melodrama available in the medium, bar none. I'm not just talking about the "big seven," either -- the canon of characters popularized as a group in Grant Morrison's JLA relaunch. His run may have cemented my dedication to the team, but I've always admired DC's eclectic roster, and I think the "rotating chair" concept is one that benefits the League on a functional and fictional level, as a crime-fighting task force and a driving force in graphic literature. Bottom line, the Justice League isn't just one particular incarnation or collection of superheroes. It's DC Comics' chance to really show off their chops.
Unfortunately, DC doesn't know how to corral the horses in their stable. Like a painter cursed with perfectionism forever touching up his masterpiece, DC's canon has been revamped, repackaged, and relaunched so many times that the characters' cumulative effort, the League itself, often suffers from comic book crib death. The last ongoing JLA title, for example, lasted a mere 125 issues before the latest crisis pressed the proverbial restart button on the DCU. Before the end, the League went through three different Green Lanterns, if you count Hal Jordan's return in the eleventh hour. In retrospect, until the '80s, readers could pick up any issue of any DC title with little concern about cosmic continuity. Sure, some issues didn't make sense in the context of previous story arcs, including the existence of Earths ad infinitum, but the entertainment factor often overshadowed any potential confusion. Our heroes' adventures were fun. The Justice League was fun. Now, with a new line-up on the horizon, I don't trust the title. The series that I most looked forward to makes me cringe at the thought of how long (or, how short) it will last this time.
Enter JLA: Classified. A series dedicated to JL adventures from the past, these tales by rotating creative teams are free of all that baggage. Further, since the stories are essentially stand-alone mini-series, readers can come and go from the book depending on their tastes. I picked up the Ellis/Guise arc and took a break for a bit; now, I'm back for "Sacred Trust," a six-issue commitment that, if following installments live up to the first one, I can live with. Written by Chaykin, no stranger to a superhero tale with political intrigue, "Sacred Trust" begins with the League essentially disobeying the UN's warning to ignore two warring Middle Eastern countries, each building a metahuman army. More so than the snapshots of action, the driving force behind this yarn is the relationship between the heroes; as a diplomat himself, Aquaman insists that the League honor the UN's position, but Batman refuses as his fight for justice is accountable to no single government. Even Superman insists, "As a visitor to this planet, my loyalties are to its people, not its governing bodies." The League does shed their spandex to go undercover as civilians, so the next chapter should offer an interesting take on how their secret identities can be used for or against their favor. Looks the League likes to take leave of its baggage, too, from time to time.
Of course, the ideas presented in this arc are not new. In JLA, we saw the League fight as their civilian selves in the Mark Waid story that physically separated the heroes from their secret identities. And in "Golden Perfect," the League controversially tackled the troubles of a sovereign nation. Still, this is the group at its finest, slightly at odds with one another, which makes them human, but nevertheless divided for justice, which makes them heroes. No matter what else may happen to these characters, at least that will never change.
(Don't remind me about Parallax, okay?)
You know, without the Justice League, Marvel Comics as we know it may never have sprung forth from the mind of Stan Lee. The League's success inspired Lee's editor to prod Stan into creating their very own super-team, and the Fantastic Four was born. I'm sure you can find a more accurate history lesson somewhere on-line, but those are the essential facts. DC has always set the stage for the medium's concept of superhero fiction: from Batman: Year One came Spider-man: Chapter One. From Crisis on Infinite Earths came The Infinity Gaunlet. And this is just on the DC versus Marvel scale; other publishers have demonstrated similar trends. Believe me. Their characters just didn't have the history to stand up to the burden of such epic storytelling. Again, DC proves that their roster simply has the chops. Like everything else, the Justice League has overcome it. Even if it's classified.
Wednesday, September 20, 2006
Looney Tunes #141
Looney Tunes #141, October 2006, DC Comics
various contributors
When I hastily burst into Borders just a few hours ago to find today’s comic book, I was already determined to avoid the superhero material. I know from experience that most mainstream bookstores have little to offer in the newsstand edition variety; you’re lucky to find anything more than superheroes, Star Wars, and cartoon-based books, like The Simpsons issue I reviewed earlier this week. I flipped through a few Dark Horse offerings but opted for the latest Looney Tunes. I figure I would’ve resorted to it sooner or later anyway. I guess I’m glad it was sooner, because after tonight’s review it will be behind me.
When I was a kid, I studied the classic Disney and Warner Bros. cartoons. I can draw, but I don’t have the talent or the patience to complete a comic book, so I was intrigued by the slow and steady cell-by-cell process of animation. Someone else paints the backgrounds while I just draw the characters over and over again? Sign me up! Kids draw the same cartoon characters all the time, usually in a subconscious attempt to hone their reproduction of the character to the point of perfection. This was me. I reckon I sketched model sheets for Mickey Mouse and Bugs Bunny more than their actual animators did. I mean, I was no Chuck Jones, but in retrospect, I could’ve been onto something. Now, I’m stuck exclusively sketching caricatures of myself. Maybe I’ll get around to finishing a flipbook of myself drawing myself.
It would be better than Looney Tunes #141. Featuring four short stories starring your favorite Warner Bro. characters, each by a different creative team, Looney Tunes #141 struck me as a rush job, an obligatory title that DC Comics is contracted to publish as a subsidiary of the WB. I didn’t expect an opus or anything; I just imagined that a comic book starring characters as old as the medium itself would exude more artistic integrity. Warner Bros. cartoons relied on more than sight gags and pratfalls. In the context of their heyday, the ‘50s and ‘60s, Bugs and company were the Simpsons of cinema, boasting a subtle social commentary that attracted adults as much as they enraptured their younger audience. Maybe humor was simpler then, sans the satiric complexities we’ve constructed to maintain our ever-waning attention spans. Nevertheless, the next time Boomerang airs a Foghorn Leghorn marathon, watch it. Really watch it. I dare you not to utter an astonished “huh” when you realize how sophisticated those old ‘toons really are.
But I digress. Looney Tunes #141. Four short stories. In the first, Porky Pig brings an ailing Sylvester the Cat to a dentist that turns out to be a mad scientist on the hunt for brains. Sylvester disguises himself as the Tooth Fairy, and while the scientist and his aid, the big red lovable monster Gossamer, rush to their teeth collection to cash in, Porky and Sylvester split for ice cream. The second story stars Honey Bunny (I think that’s her name – Bugs’ girlfriend from Space Jam) as “Beauty” to the Tasmanian Devil’s beast. In this incarnation, Taz can’t eat any of the enchanted food in his castle, so Honey suggests he leave the fortress for a bite to eat in town. The transformed help don’t appreciate her advice, however, and in the end, it looks like she’s for dinner. Ha.
The third tale is a Porky/Daffy buddy piece, in which Daffy represents a failed ACME drain cleanser, and I should start a new paragraph here to say that, at this point in the issue, the quality of the work from both a writing and illustrative perspective unravels. Porky is inconsistently drawn, and he isn’t too hard to draw, while Daffy’s goofy dialogue is downright annoying. I wish I jotted down a few of the incomprehensible lines, but trust me. Daffy’s usual bravado gave way to sheer stupidity. Finally, in the last tale, Bugs and Daffy, who in this yarn is written with his lisp intact, visit Yosemite Sam’s short staffed roadside restaurant, where in typical fashion Bugs dons a waitress uniform, mixes up the orders, and a chaotic food fight ensues. The writer doesn’t bother to actually end the story. Instead, Bugs inexplicably pulls out a black and white camera and snaps a shot for young readers to color. In my opinion, a comic book truly intended for kids shouldn’t be so text intensive, but space permitting, the text should be something a parent could read to their child without sounding like an idiot. The Roadrunner’s “beep beep” is more amusing than this trite.
Obviously, my disappointment in Looney Tunes #141 comes from my fond childhood memories of original cartoons. Even the C-list characters, like the Bookworm or that kangaroo with the boxing gloves that Sylvester often mistook as a big mouse, had a touch of class, like one big rat pack (pardon the pun) of classic animation. This clout isn’t respected anymore. These characters have been too franchised for their own good, repackaged in ridiculous molds of modern interpretation to really matter as the founding fathers they actually are. Case in point: the Loonatics. Check out this upcoming Saturday morning’s Kids’ WB! season premieres if you don’t know what I’m talking about. Have we forsaken our childhood tendencies to achieve perfection? Yes, if drawing comics tries my patience, it’s no wonder I can barely watch the cartoons in which I once took refuge. When I behold today’s excuses for Bugs, Daffy, and Porky, sometimes I wonder, “Is this really all, folks?”
various contributors
When I hastily burst into Borders just a few hours ago to find today’s comic book, I was already determined to avoid the superhero material. I know from experience that most mainstream bookstores have little to offer in the newsstand edition variety; you’re lucky to find anything more than superheroes, Star Wars, and cartoon-based books, like The Simpsons issue I reviewed earlier this week. I flipped through a few Dark Horse offerings but opted for the latest Looney Tunes. I figure I would’ve resorted to it sooner or later anyway. I guess I’m glad it was sooner, because after tonight’s review it will be behind me.
When I was a kid, I studied the classic Disney and Warner Bros. cartoons. I can draw, but I don’t have the talent or the patience to complete a comic book, so I was intrigued by the slow and steady cell-by-cell process of animation. Someone else paints the backgrounds while I just draw the characters over and over again? Sign me up! Kids draw the same cartoon characters all the time, usually in a subconscious attempt to hone their reproduction of the character to the point of perfection. This was me. I reckon I sketched model sheets for Mickey Mouse and Bugs Bunny more than their actual animators did. I mean, I was no Chuck Jones, but in retrospect, I could’ve been onto something. Now, I’m stuck exclusively sketching caricatures of myself. Maybe I’ll get around to finishing a flipbook of myself drawing myself.
It would be better than Looney Tunes #141. Featuring four short stories starring your favorite Warner Bro. characters, each by a different creative team, Looney Tunes #141 struck me as a rush job, an obligatory title that DC Comics is contracted to publish as a subsidiary of the WB. I didn’t expect an opus or anything; I just imagined that a comic book starring characters as old as the medium itself would exude more artistic integrity. Warner Bros. cartoons relied on more than sight gags and pratfalls. In the context of their heyday, the ‘50s and ‘60s, Bugs and company were the Simpsons of cinema, boasting a subtle social commentary that attracted adults as much as they enraptured their younger audience. Maybe humor was simpler then, sans the satiric complexities we’ve constructed to maintain our ever-waning attention spans. Nevertheless, the next time Boomerang airs a Foghorn Leghorn marathon, watch it. Really watch it. I dare you not to utter an astonished “huh” when you realize how sophisticated those old ‘toons really are.
But I digress. Looney Tunes #141. Four short stories. In the first, Porky Pig brings an ailing Sylvester the Cat to a dentist that turns out to be a mad scientist on the hunt for brains. Sylvester disguises himself as the Tooth Fairy, and while the scientist and his aid, the big red lovable monster Gossamer, rush to their teeth collection to cash in, Porky and Sylvester split for ice cream. The second story stars Honey Bunny (I think that’s her name – Bugs’ girlfriend from Space Jam) as “Beauty” to the Tasmanian Devil’s beast. In this incarnation, Taz can’t eat any of the enchanted food in his castle, so Honey suggests he leave the fortress for a bite to eat in town. The transformed help don’t appreciate her advice, however, and in the end, it looks like she’s for dinner. Ha.
The third tale is a Porky/Daffy buddy piece, in which Daffy represents a failed ACME drain cleanser, and I should start a new paragraph here to say that, at this point in the issue, the quality of the work from both a writing and illustrative perspective unravels. Porky is inconsistently drawn, and he isn’t too hard to draw, while Daffy’s goofy dialogue is downright annoying. I wish I jotted down a few of the incomprehensible lines, but trust me. Daffy’s usual bravado gave way to sheer stupidity. Finally, in the last tale, Bugs and Daffy, who in this yarn is written with his lisp intact, visit Yosemite Sam’s short staffed roadside restaurant, where in typical fashion Bugs dons a waitress uniform, mixes up the orders, and a chaotic food fight ensues. The writer doesn’t bother to actually end the story. Instead, Bugs inexplicably pulls out a black and white camera and snaps a shot for young readers to color. In my opinion, a comic book truly intended for kids shouldn’t be so text intensive, but space permitting, the text should be something a parent could read to their child without sounding like an idiot. The Roadrunner’s “beep beep” is more amusing than this trite.
Obviously, my disappointment in Looney Tunes #141 comes from my fond childhood memories of original cartoons. Even the C-list characters, like the Bookworm or that kangaroo with the boxing gloves that Sylvester often mistook as a big mouse, had a touch of class, like one big rat pack (pardon the pun) of classic animation. This clout isn’t respected anymore. These characters have been too franchised for their own good, repackaged in ridiculous molds of modern interpretation to really matter as the founding fathers they actually are. Case in point: the Loonatics. Check out this upcoming Saturday morning’s Kids’ WB! season premieres if you don’t know what I’m talking about. Have we forsaken our childhood tendencies to achieve perfection? Yes, if drawing comics tries my patience, it’s no wonder I can barely watch the cartoons in which I once took refuge. When I behold today’s excuses for Bugs, Daffy, and Porky, sometimes I wonder, “Is this really all, folks?”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
